· Mason Everett · Reviews · 9 min read
10 Best Ice Cube Trays With Lids 2025 Reviewed
Finding the perfect ice cube tray can feel surprisingly complicated, especially with so many options available.
You need something that is easy to fill, releases cubes without a struggle, and prevents freezer odors from tainting your ice.
We evaluated dozens of models based on key criteria like material quality, durability, ease of use, and overall value for money.
This guide focuses on safe, BPA-free options to ensure your drinks are always fresh and pure.
Let’s dive into our detailed reviews to help you find the Best Ice Cube Tray With Lid for your needs, ensuring you make a confident and informed choice.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we've selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
DOQAUS Ice Tray with Lid and Bin
This all-in-one system includes four trays, a storage bin, and a scoop. Its sturdy, BPA-free construction and easy-release design make it a comprehensive solution for any household.
Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays 4-Pack
Offering incredible value, this four-pack provides a total of 56 cubes. The flexible silicone bottoms ensure effortless ice removal, while the stackable lids save precious freezer space.
OXO Good Grips 2-Pack
OXO reinvents the ice tray with a unique sliding lid that lets you release as many cubes as you need. Its sturdy, stackable design and odor-blocking cover make it a top performer.
Tvmania Silicone Ice Trays
Made from heat-resistant, food-grade silicone, these trays are great for more than just water. Use them for baby food, chocolates, or cocktails; they are freezer, microwave, and dishwasher safe.
ChefAide 4-Pack 56-Cube Trays
Perfect for parties or large families, this set makes 56 cubes at once. The hybrid plastic and silicone design offers both structure and flexibility for easy release.
OXO Good Grips No-Spill Tray
This tray features a sealed silicone lid that prevents spills even when stored at an angle. The comfortable handle and easy-release rounded cubes make it exceptionally user-friendly.
Excnorm Large Silicone Trays
For those who prefer slow-melting ice, this set creates impressive 1.9-inch cubes perfect for whiskey and cocktails. The flexible silicone makes releasing these large cubes a simple task.
DclobTop Round Ice Cube Tray
Elevate your drinks with perfectly round ice balls. This kit includes trays and a storage bin to make up to 62 mini spheres, adding a touch of fun and elegance to any beverage.
WIBIMEN Compact Round Ice Trays
Ideal for smaller freezers or personal fridges, this compact set makes stylish round ice balls. The durable plastic design allows for a quick twist-and-release action.
PHINOX Press-to-Release Tray
This innovative tray features a press-plate mechanism for instant, no-fuss ice release. The set comes with two trays, a large-capacity bin, and a scoop for ultimate convenience.
10 Best Ice Cube Tray With Lid
A great ice cube tray does more than just freeze water; it enhances your entire beverage experience. The right tray prevents spills, protects ice from freezer odors, and releases cubes without a struggle. Get ready to discover the top performers that will change the way you make ice.
Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays 4-Pack
Best for Bulk Ice Making on a Budget
The Airabc 4-Pack is a fantastic choice for anyone needing a large supply of ice without breaking the bank.
This set includes four trays, each making 14 well-sized cubes, for a total of 56.
Made from LFGB certified, BPA-free food-grade silicone and PP material, these trays are both safe and durable.
The standout feature is the soft TPE base combined with flexible polypropylene edges, which makes releasing ice cubes incredibly simple.
A slight twist and a gentle push from the bottom are all it takes, eliminating the frustrating struggle associated with rigid plastic trays.
The included removable lids are a game-changer, preventing spills during transport to the freezer and allowing for neat, space-saving stacking.
They also effectively seal out freezer odors, ensuring your ice tastes fresh and clean every time.
This set is perfect for families, parties, or anyone who enjoys having plenty of ice on hand for coffee, cocktails, or other beverages.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Capacity | 56 Cubes (14 per tray) |
| Set Includes | 4 Trays, 4 Lids |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- 4-Pack Value: Get a total of 56 ice cubes, perfect for parties and families.
- Easy-Release Design: Soft TPE base lets you pop cubes out effortlessly.
- Stackable Lids: Removable covers prevent spills and save freezer space.
- BPA-Free Materials: Made from safe, food-grade silicone and PP for peace of mind.
- Dishwasher Safe: Simplifies cleanup for ultimate convenience.
- Odor Prevention: Lids protect ice from absorbing unwanted freezer smells.
What We Like
- Excellent value for a four-pack set
- Ice cubes are very easy to remove
- Stackable design is great for organization
- Durable and flexible materials
- BPA-free and safe for food contact
What We Don't Like
- Lids are not 100% watertight, so avoid tilting when full
- Cubes are a standard, smaller size
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the Airabc set for its exceptional value and user-friendly design.
During testing, the easy-release mechanism performed flawlessly, with cubes popping out cleanly without any breakage.
The stackable lids fit securely, which we found great for organizing a crowded freezer.
The materials felt robust and held up well to repeated freezing and washing.
For the price, getting four high-quality, lidded trays is an unbeatable deal that combines quantity with quality, making it a top recommendation for most households.
User Experience
Users consistently praise this set for how easy it is to remove the ice cubes, often highlighting the flexible silicone bottom as a key feature.
Many appreciate the stackable lids for saving freezer space and keeping ice fresh.
The durability is another common point of positive feedback, with customers noting the trays do not crack or become brittle like traditional plastic ones.
It is a popular choice for everything from daily use to preparing for social gatherings, offering reliable performance and convenience.
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
Best All-in-One Ice Making System
The DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray set is a complete solution for making, storing, and serving ice.
This comprehensive kit includes four ice trays, a large-capacity storage bin, removable lids with convenient lifters, and a handy scoop.
It is designed for those who want an organized and efficient ice-making process.
Made from premium, BPA-free silicone and PP material, the trays are both durable and safe, capable of withstanding long-term freezing without cracking.
The hybrid TPE and plastic construction ensures that ice removal is a breeze; the soft bottom allows you to push cubes out easily without awkward twisting.
The stackable design, combined with the storage container, maximizes freezer space and keeps your ice neatly contained and protected from freezer odors.
It is an ideal system for RVs, home bars, parties, or anyone who values convenience and organization in their kitchen.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Set Includes | 4 Trays, 1 Storage Bin, 1 Scoop, Lids |
| Cube Size | 1 ounce / 27 ml |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Complete Kit: Includes 4 trays, a storage bin, lids, and an ice scoop.
- Easy Ice Removal: Soft TPE bottom for effortless cube release.
- Lid Lifter Design: Covers are easy to remove thanks to small tabs.
- BPA-Free & Odor-Free: Constructed with high-quality, food-safe materials.
- Space-Saving Storage: Trays stack neatly inside the bin to keep your freezer organized.
- Durable Construction: Designed to resist cracking and breaking in the freezer.
What We Like
- All-in-one system is very convenient
- Large storage capacity for ice
- Trays are sturdy and well-made
- Easy to remove ice cubes
- Keeps ice fresh and odor-free
What We Don't Like
- Takes up more freezer space than individual trays
- Lids seal for stacking but are not fully leak-proof
Why We Selected This Product
This DOQAUS set earned its spot for being a perfectly integrated system.
We loved the inclusion of the storage bin and scoop, which elevates it from just trays to a full-service ice station.
The lid lifters are a thoughtful touch, making them easy to remove even when frozen solid.
During our evaluation, the materials proved to be robust and odor-free.
The ability to make a large batch of ice and store it in the bin for easy access is incredibly practical, especially when entertaining guests.
It represents a smart, well-designed product that solves multiple problems at once.
User Experience
Customers rave about the convenience of having an all-in-one system.
The storage bin is frequently mentioned as a favorite feature, allowing users to stockpile ice.
The easy-release bottoms are another point of high praise, ending the frustration of traditional trays.
Many users also appreciate the sturdy build quality, noting that it feels much more premium than cheaper alternatives.
The compact, stackable nature makes it a hit with those who have limited freezer space but still want a high-capacity ice solution.
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack
Best for Innovative and Controlled Release
OXO is known for thoughtful design, and this ice cube tray is a prime example.
This 2-pack features a unique sliding lid that sets it apart from the competition.
Instead of removing the entire lid, you can slide it open to release as many or as few ice cubes as you need, keeping the remaining cubes covered and protected.
This innovative feature minimizes spills and prevents cubes from absorbing freezer odors.
The trays themselves are sturdy and designed for efficient stacking, saving valuable freezer real estate.
The rounded shape of the ice cubes is not just for aesthetics; it is engineered to release more easily from the tray.
Made from BPA-free materials and being dishwasher safe, these trays offer both clever functionality and easy maintenance.
It is an excellent choice for those who appreciate smart design and want precise control over their ice dispensing.
Product Specs
| Material | Plastic |
| Set Includes | 2 Trays with Sliding Lids |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Special Feature | Sliding Lid |
Features
- Unique Sliding Lid: Dispense the exact number of cubes you need.
- Sturdy & Stackable: Solid frame allows for efficient stacking in the freezer.
- Odor-Blocking Cover: Prevents ice from absorbing unwanted freezer smells.
- Easy-Release Shape: Innovative rounded cubes pop out easily.
- BPA-Free: Made with safe, high-quality materials.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy to clean for hassle-free maintenance.
What We Like
- Clever sliding lid for controlled dispensing
- Excellent build quality and durability
- Effective odor protection
- Stacks securely in the freezer
- Easy to clean
What We Don't Like
- Higher price point per tray
- The sliding mechanism can be stiff at first
Why We Selected This Product
We chose the OXO Good Grips tray for its genuinely innovative sliding lid.
In our tests, this feature worked exceptionally well, allowing us to dispense a single cube without touching the others or making a mess.
The build quality is typical of OXO—solid, durable, and thoughtfully designed.
The rounded cubes released cleanly with a simple twist.
It is a premium-feeling product that solves a common annoyance with standard ice trays, making it a standout for design-conscious consumers who value functionality.
User Experience
Users love the sliding lid, frequently calling it a brilliant and practical innovation.
The ability to get just one or two cubes without wrestling with the tray is a huge plus.
The sturdy construction and stackability are also highly praised.
Many report that the cover effectively prevents freezer burn and odors, resulting in better-tasting ice.
While it's a simpler set without a large bin, customers appreciate its focused, high-quality design for everyday use.
Tvmania Silicone Ice Trays
Best for Versatile Kitchen Use
The Tvmania Ice Cube Trays are designed for ultimate versatility.
Made from 100% food-grade, BPA-free silicone, this set of two is not just for freezing water.
Their impressive heat resistance, from -40°F to 428°F, means you can use them in the freezer, refrigerator, microwave, and dishwasher.
This makes them perfect for creating frozen baby food portions, homemade chocolates, mini desserts, or freezing herbs in olive oil.
Each tray produces 15 perfectly sized cubes, and the flexible silicone material makes releasing them as easy as pushing from the bottom.
The included lids fit securely, locking in freshness and preventing spills and odor contamination in the freezer.
Their compact dimensions ensure they fit easily into any freezer without taking up too much room.
If you are looking for an ice cube tray that can do more, this is an outstanding and highly adaptable choice.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone |
| Total Capacity | 30 Cubes (15 per tray) |
| Set Includes | 2 Trays, 2 Lids |
| Temperature Range | -40°F to 428°F |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dimensions | 7.3" x 5.1" x 1.2" |
Features
- Wide Temperature Range: Safe from -40°F to 428°F for versatile use.
- 100% Food-Grade Silicone: BPA-free and safe for direct food contact.
- Flexible & Easy Release: Simply push from the bottom to release cubes.
- Secure Lids: Keep contents fresh and prevent freezer odors.
- Multi-Purpose: Ideal for ice, baby food, chocolate, and more.
- Dishwasher & Microwave Safe: Easy to clean and highly versatile.
What We Like
- Extremely versatile for various kitchen tasks
- Very easy to release cubes due to flexible silicone
- Wide temperature resistance
- Compact and easy to store
- Comes with effective lids
What We Don't Like
- Silicone can be floppy when filled, requiring careful transport
- May absorb strong odors if not washed properly
Why We Selected This Product
We were impressed by the sheer versatility of the Tvmania trays.
Their wide temperature range opens up a world of culinary possibilities beyond simple ice cubes.
We tested them for freezing broth and they worked perfectly, with the cubes popping out cleanly.
The silicone is soft and pliable yet feels durable.
The lids provide a good seal, which is crucial when freezing things other than water.
It is a high-quality, multi-purpose kitchen tool that offers great value for its flexibility.
User Experience
Many users purchase these trays specifically for making baby food and praise how easy it is to pop out single frozen portions.
The flexibility of the silicone is a consistent highlight in reviews, with customers appreciating that there's no need to twist or bang the tray.
The secure-fitting lids are also a popular feature.
People love being able to use one product for so many different tasks, from making fun-shaped ice for cocktails to creating homemade candies.
ChefAide 4-Pack 56-Cube Trays
Best for High-Capacity Ice Production
When you need a lot of ice, the ChefAide 4-Pack delivers.
This set is designed for maximum output, producing a total of 56 rectangular ice cubes at once.
It is the perfect solution for parties, large families, or anyone who stocks up on ice for coolers.
The trays feature a clever hybrid construction: the top frame is made of sturdy plastic, which provides structure and prevents sagging when filling and carrying, while the bottom of each cube compartment is soft silicone.
This design offers the best of both worlds—stability and effortless release.
You no longer need to twist and fight with the tray; just push on the silicone bottom and the ice pops right out.
The included removable lids allow for neat stacking, saving space and protecting the ice from freezer odors.
These dishwasher-safe trays are a practical and durable choice for high-volume ice needs.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Capacity | 56 Cubes (14 per tray) |
| Set Includes | 4 Trays, 4 Lids |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- High Capacity: Four trays produce a total of 56 ice cubes.
- Hybrid Design: Combines a sturdy plastic frame with a flexible silicone bottom.
- Effortless Release: Simply push the soft silicone base to pop out ice.
- Stackable with Lids: Space-saving design keeps your freezer organized and ice clean.
- Durable Materials: Built to withstand long-term freezing without cracking.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy to clean after use.
What We Like
- Makes a large quantity of ice
- Smart design is both sturdy and flexible
- Very easy to release cubes
- Stackable lids work well
- Great value for a 4-pack
What We Don't Like
- Need to wait a moment after freezing for easiest lid removal
- Rectangular cubes are functional but less decorative
Why We Selected This Product
The ChefAide set impressed us with its smart hybrid design.
The rigid frame made the trays much easier to handle than all-silicone models, preventing spills.
The silicone bottoms worked exactly as advertised, releasing cubes with minimal effort.
We also appreciated the high capacity and the efficient, stackable design.
It's a robust, well-thought-out product that excels at its primary job: making a lot of ice easily.
This set is ideal for anyone who is tired of flimsy trays and needs a reliable, high-volume solution.
User Experience
Users consistently praise the dual-material construction.
The sturdy plastic frame is a frequently mentioned benefit, making the trays easy to fill and move.
The easy-release silicone bottoms are a huge hit, with many reviewers expressing relief at no longer having to struggle with old-fashioned trays.
The stackable design is also a big win for those with packed freezers.
It is often recommended for its durability and practical, user-friendly features.
OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
Best for Preventing Spills
The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray is engineered to solve one of the most common frustrations of making ice: spilling water on the way to the freezer.
This tray features a flexible silicone lid that creates a secure seal, trapping water inside.
This allows you to carry and store the tray at an angle without leaks, a huge advantage for crowded or uneven freezer shelves.
A comfortable handle provides a firm, secure grip during transport.
The innovative rounded shape of the ice cubes is designed for easy release, so you don't have to twist the tray excessively.
The lid also serves to protect the ice from absorbing any stray freezer odors, ensuring your drinks taste exactly as they should.
Being top-rack dishwasher safe, cleanup is as simple as its operation.
This single tray is perfect for anyone who prioritizes a mess-free experience.
Product Specs
| Material | Plastic & Silicone Lid |
| Capacity | 14 Cubes |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes (Top-rack) |
| Special Feature | No-Spill Sealed Lid |
Features
- Sealed Silicone Lid: Prevents spills and allows for angled storage.
- Comfortable Handle: Provides a secure grip for easy filling and carrying.
- Easy-Release Cubes: Rounded shape helps ice pop out without a struggle.
- Odor Protection: Lid keeps ice fresh and free from freezer smells.
- Top-Rack Dishwasher Safe: Simple and convenient to clean.
- BPA-Free Construction: Made with safe, high-quality materials.
What We Like
- Truly spill-proof design
- Can be stored at an angle
- Ergonomic and easy to handle
- Cubes release easily
- Effectively blocks freezer odors
What We Don't Like
- Only one tray per package
- Silicone lid can be a bit tricky to seal perfectly at first
Why We Selected This Product
This tray's no-spill feature is genuinely effective.
During our tests, we filled it, sealed the lid, and were able to tilt it significantly without a single drop escaping.
This is a game-changer for anyone with a shaky hand or a cluttered freezer.
The handle is another excellent ergonomic touch that adds to the user-friendly experience.
While it is just a single tray, its specialized design and flawless execution make it a must-have for those who value clean, hassle-free ice making.
The OXO Better Guarantee also adds peace of mind.
User Experience
Users are overwhelmingly positive about the no-spill functionality, with many calling it the best ice tray they have ever owned.
The ability to store it at an angle is a frequently praised feature, especially for those with chest freezers or packed drawers.
The easy-to-grip handle and simple cube release also receive high marks.
Reviewers confirm that the lid does an excellent job of keeping odors out, resulting in clean-tasting ice cubes.
Excnorm Large Silicone Trays
Best for Craft Cocktails and Whiskey
For the serious beverage enthusiast, the Excnorm Silicone Ice Cube Trays are a game-changer.
This 3-pack is designed to create massive 1.9-inch square cubes that melt slowly, chilling your drink without diluting it quickly.
This makes them ideal for whiskey, bourbon, and craft cocktails where preserving the integrity of the flavor is paramount.
Made entirely of flexible, food-grade, BPA-free silicone, these trays make releasing the large cubes incredibly easy.
A simple push from the bottom is all that is required.
The set comes with removable lids that help prevent spills and block freezer odors, although they are designed not to be 100% sealed to allow for water expansion during freezing.
This thoughtful design prevents the trays from bursting.
If you want to elevate your home bar experience, these trays produce professional-quality ice cubes with minimal effort.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone |
| Cube Size | 1.9" x 1.9" x 1.9" |
| Total Capacity | 18 Cubes (6 per tray) |
| Set Includes | 3 Trays, 3 Lids |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
Features
- Large 1.9-Inch Cubes: Perfect for cocktails and whiskey, as they melt slowly.
- Food-Grade Silicone: BPA-free, flexible, and safe for direct food contact.
- Non-Stick Design: Cubes are easy to remove by pushing the flexible bottom.
- Removable Lids: Help prevent spills and protect against freezer odors.
- 3-Pack Set: Provides a total of 18 large ice cubes.
- Durable & Flexible: Resists cracking and is easy to handle.
What We Like
- Creates large, slow-melting cubes
- Very easy to release ice
- Made from high-quality, flexible silicone
- Great for preserving the flavor of drinks
- Good value with three trays included
What We Don't Like
- Lids are not fully sealed to prevent bursting
- Silicone material can be flimsy when carrying
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this set for its ability to produce genuinely large, slow-melting ice cubes, perfect for spirits.
The 100% silicone construction was highly effective; the massive cubes released without any cracking or difficulty, which can be a problem with large-format rigid trays.
The size and quality of the ice produced significantly improved the drinking experience in our tests, keeping beverages cold for longer.
The 3-pack offers great value for anyone looking to step up their cocktail game.
User Experience
Home bartenders and whiskey lovers are the biggest fans of this product.
They consistently praise the large size of the cubes and their slow melting rate.
The ease of removal from the flexible silicone molds is another major selling point.
Users appreciate that they can finally make bar-quality ice at home.
While some note the lids don't create a watertight seal, they understand this is an intentional design feature to prevent cracking.
DclobTop Round Ice Cube Tray
Best for Making Fun Round Ice Balls
Add a touch of whimsy and elegance to your drinks with the DclobTop Round Ice Cube Tray set.
This kit allows you to create up to 62 perfectly round 1.2-inch mini ice balls, which look fantastic in cocktails, iced coffee, or even a simple glass of water.
The set includes two trays for making the spheres, a storage bin to keep them in, and a scoop for easy serving.
Made from premium, food-grade, BPA-free PP materials, these trays are durable, safe, and odor-free.
The flexible, non-stick design makes releasing the ice balls a breeze—a gentle twist is all it takes to pop them out.
The stackable design of the trays and the inclusion of the storage bin help maximize freezer space and keep everything organized.
This set is perfect for anyone who wants to make their beverages a little more special and fun.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade PP Plastic |
| Ice Shape | Round Ball (1.2-inch) |
| Total Capacity | 62 Ice Balls |
| Set Includes | 2 Trays, 1 Storage Bin, 1 Scoop, Lid |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
Features
- Makes 62 Mini Ice Balls: Create a large quantity of 1.2-inch round ice spheres.
- Complete Set: Includes trays, a storage bin, and a scoop.
- Stackable & Space-Saving: Keeps your freezer tidy and organized.
- Premium Food-Grade Material: BPA-free, durable, and odor-free for safe use.
- Effortless Ice Release: Flexible, non-stick design makes it easy to pop out ice balls.
- Versatile Use: Great for cocktails, coffee, whiskey, and other creative drinks.
What We Like
- Creates fun and attractive round ice
- Comes as a complete set with storage
- Easy to release the ice spheres
- Good capacity for parties
- Stackable design saves space
What We Don't Like
- Filling the small holes can be a bit tricky
- The two halves of the tray must be aligned properly for perfect spheres
Why We Selected This Product
This set stands out for its ability to easily produce a large quantity of attractive, round ice.
We found the two-part trays simple to fill and seal, and they consistently produced well-formed spheres.
The storage bin is a huge plus, allowing you to build up a collection of ice balls for a party.
The release mechanism worked well, and the entire system felt sturdy and well-designed.
It is a fantastic choice for adding visual appeal to drinks without sacrificing convenience.
User Experience
Users love the fun, perfectly round ice balls this kit produces.
They are a big hit at parties and with kids.
The all-in-one system with the storage bin and scoop is highly appreciated for its convenience and organization.
Many reviewers comment on how easy the trays are to use and clean.
The durable material is also a point of praise, as it doesn't feel flimsy or cheap.
It is a popular choice for everything from daily iced coffee to special occasion cocktails.
WIBIMEN Compact Round Ice Trays
Best Compact Design for Small Freezers
The WIBIMEN Ice Cube Tray set is the perfect solution for those with limited freezer space.
This compact system is designed to fit easily into smaller personal fridges or packed freezer drawers.
It produces stylish, 0.8-inch round ice balls that are not only aesthetically pleasing but also cool drinks down quickly.
The set includes two trays, a lid, and a storage bin.
Unlike silicone molds, these trays are made of durable plastic, which makes releasing the ice incredibly easy—after removing from the freezer, a gentle twist is all that is needed to pop the ice balls out.
The food-grade materials ensure that your ice is safe and free of any unwanted tastes.
This set is ideal for adding a touch of style to everyday drinks like cocktails, coffee, or infused water without sacrificing precious freezer space.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Plastic |
| Ice Shape | Round Ball (0.8-inch) |
| Set Includes | 2 Trays, 1 Bin, 1 Lid |
| BPA-Free | Yes (Assumed from Food-Grade) |
| Special Feature | Compact, Easy-Twist Release |
Features
- Easy Release: Durable plastic allows for a simple twist-and-pop release.
- Compact Design: Perfect for small personal fridges, RVs, or crowded freezers.
- Complete Set: Includes two trays, a lid, and a storage bin.
- Stylish Ice Balls: Creates small, 0.8-inch round spheres to enhance your drinks.
- Food-Grade Materials: Long-lasting, safe, and designed for well-being.
- Multiple Uses: Ideal for cocktails, coffee, and fruit-infused beverages.
What We Like
- Very compact and space-saving
- Extremely easy to release ice
- Stylish and aesthetically pleasing ice balls
- Good quality, durable materials
- Includes a convenient storage bin
What We Don't Like
- Makes smaller ice balls that melt faster
- Lower total ice capacity than larger sets
Why We Selected This Product
We were impressed by the compact and efficient design of this set.
It is noticeably smaller than many other systems with bins, making it genuinely suitable for tight spaces.
The twist-release mechanism of the hard plastic was surprisingly effective and faster than pushing out individual spheres from silicone.
The quality of the food-grade plastic felt high, and the entire unit stacks together neatly.
It is a great option for dorm rooms, apartments, or anyone who wants a stylish ice solution without the bulk.
User Experience
Users with small fridges or RVs rave about the compact size of this set.
They appreciate that they can have a full ice-making system without it taking over their freezer.
The easy, twist-release feature is a consistent highlight, with many preferring it to silicone.
The cute, small ice balls are also a hit, perfect for cooling drinks quickly.
It is often described as a well-designed, space-saving, and practical product.
PHINOX Press-to-Release Tray
Best for Effortless, One-Press Release
The PHINOX Ice Cube Tray set revolutionizes the ice removal process with its innovative press-type release mechanism.
Say goodbye to twisting and banging trays forever.
With this system, you simply place the frozen tray upside down on the storage bin, put the included pillar plate on top, and press down.
All 32 ice cubes are released instantly and fall neatly into the bin.
The set comes with two trays (for a total of 64 cubes), the press plate, a large storage bin that holds nearly 120 cubes, an airtight lid, and an ice scoop.
Made from food-grade, BPA-free material, it is a safe and durable choice.
The sealing lid prevents spills and keeps ice from absorbing freezer odors.
This patented design is perfect for anyone who has struggled with traditional trays and wants the ultimate in convenience.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade PP Plastic |
| Total Capacity | 64 Cubes (32 per tray) |
| Set Includes | 2 Trays, 1 Bin, 1 Scoop, 1 Press Lid, 1 Sealing Lid |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | No |
| Dimensions | 10.2" x 5.1" x 5.7" |
Features
- One-Press Release: Patented push-type design releases all cubes at once.
- High Capacity System: Includes two 32-cube trays and a bin that holds 120 cubes.
- Complete Kit: Comes with trays, a press plate, a storage bin, a lid, and a scoop.
- Food-Grade Material: Made from safe, BPA-free PP material.
- Airtight Lid: Prevents spills and keeps ice fresh and odor-free.
- Space-Saving: All components stack together neatly in the freezer.
What We Like
- Incredibly easy and fast ice release
- Large storage bin capacity
- Complete and convenient all-in-one system
- Well-sealed lid prevents odors
- Innovative and user-friendly design
What We Don't Like
- Tray is not dishwasher safe
- Must not overfill for the release mechanism to work properly
Why We Selected This Product
The one-press release system is genuinely impressive and works exactly as advertised.
It is by far the easiest and fastest way to empty an ice tray that we have tested.
This feature alone makes it a top contender, especially for those with arthritis or limited hand strength.
The large capacity of the storage bin is another major advantage, making it perfect for parties.
The overall system is well-constructed and thoughtfully designed to eliminate all the common pain points of making ice.
User Experience
Users are amazed by the push-release feature, often describing it as magical or a game-changer.
It is a massive hit with people who have struggled with other trays in the past.
The large storage capacity and included scoop are also frequently praised for their convenience.
Reviewers note the importance of not overfilling the trays for the mechanism to work perfectly.
It is highly recommended for its innovative design and sheer ease of use.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Ice Cube Tray With Lid
Choosing the right ice cube tray can significantly improve your daily routine. Here are the key factors to consider to ensure you select a product that meets your needs perfectly.
Find Your Need - Compatibility and use case considerations
First, think about how you will use the ice. Are you a cocktail enthusiast who needs large, slow-melting cubes like those from easy release ice cube trays? Or do you need a high volume of standard cubes for everyday drinks and coolers? Consider the shape—standard squares, large spheres, or novelty shapes—and how they fit your glassware. If you plan to freeze baby food, coffee, or broth, a flexible, food-grade silicone tray is your best bet.
Budget - Setting realistic price expectations
Ice cube trays with lids range in price from around $10 for a basic set to over $30 for a comprehensive system with a storage bin and scoop. A simple 2 or 4-pack of silicone trays often falls in the $15-$20 range. Premium brands like OXO or models with innovative features like press-to-release mechanisms may cost slightly more. Determine if you need a simple solution or an all-in-one system to set a realistic budget.
Key Features - Most important technical specifications
Look for features that enhance convenience. Easy-release designs, whether through flexible silicone bottoms or mechanical aids, are crucial. Stackable lids are essential for saving freezer space and preventing odor contamination. If you entertain often, a set that includes a storage bin and scoop, similar to a dedicated ice bucket, is incredibly useful. Also, check if the materials are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
Quality & Durability - What to look for in construction
The best materials are BPA-free, food-grade silicone and sturdy PP plastic. Silicone offers flexibility for easy release, while a rigid plastic frame provides stability. Look for trays that feel robust and are designed to withstand long-term freezing without becoming brittle or cracking. A well-made tray should last for years, making it a worthwhile investment.
Brand Reputation - Importance of established manufacturers
Brands like OXO have a strong reputation for thoughtful design and durable products. However, many newer brands offer innovative and high-quality options as well. Reading user reviews can give you insight into a product’s real-world performance and durability, regardless of the brand’s name recognition. A product with consistently high ratings is usually a safe bet.
Portability/Size - Considerations for space and storage
Measure your freezer space before buying. A large system with a storage bin might be convenient, but only if it fits. If you have a small freezer, look for compact, stackable trays. For RVs or dorms, a no-spill design that can be stored at an angle is a major advantage. Consider the overall footprint of the set and how it will integrate with your existing freezer organization.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy ice cube tray with lid?
Investing in a quality ice cube tray with a lid is a surprisingly wise decision for several reasons. At first glance, it might seem like a minor kitchen accessory, but its impact on convenience, hygiene, and even the taste of your beverages is significant. A lid prevents spills on the precarious journey from the sink to the freezer, saving you from messes and wasted water. More importantly, it acts as a protective barrier, shielding your ice from absorbing odors from other foods in the freezer. This means your ice will taste like pure, clean water, not like leftover garlic bread or frozen fish.
Compared to lidless trays or the automatic ice makers in some refrigerators, lidded trays offer superior control and hygiene. Automatic ice makers can harbor mold and bacteria if not cleaned regularly, and the ice often develops an off-taste. With a dedicated tray, you control the water source and can easily wash it between uses. The long-term benefits are clear: you get consistently fresh, odor-free ice, a more organized freezer thanks to stackable designs, and the versatility to freeze other liquids like coffee or juice without cross-contamination. For a relatively small cost, a good lidded tray elevates your entire beverage experience.
What Is the Best Way to Choose ice cube tray with lid?
Choosing the perfect ice cube tray with a lid involves a few simple steps to match the product to your lifestyle.
Assess Your Primary Use: First, define what you need the ice for. Is it for chilling water and soda quickly, requiring standard-sized cubes? Or are you a whiskey aficionado who needs large, slow-melting spheres? If you plan to make frozen baby food or herb pucks, you’ll need a versatile, food-grade silicone tray.
Evaluate Your Freezer Space: Measure the available space in your freezer. This will determine whether you can accommodate a large, all-in-one system with a storage bin or if you need to stick with a more compact, stackable set of trays. Remember to check the height clearance for stacking.
Prioritize Ease of Use: The biggest complaint about ice trays is difficulty removing the cubes. Look for features that promise easy release, such as flexible silicone bottoms, rounded cube shapes, or innovative press-and-release mechanisms. If you hate cleaning, ensure the tray is dishwasher safe.
Check Material Safety: Always opt for trays made from BPA-free, food-grade materials. This is non-negotiable for anything that will come into contact with your food and drinks. Both high-quality silicone and PP plastic are excellent choices.
Common Mistakes to Avoid:
- Ignoring Lid Type: Don’t assume all lids are equal. Some are for stacking only, while others, like silicone ones, create a spill-proof seal. Choose based on your needs.
- Buying Based on Price Alone: The cheapest trays are often made from brittle plastic that cracks easily and lacks effective lids. Investing a few extra dollars in a durable, well-designed tray pays off in the long run.
- Forgetting About Capacity: A single tray might not be enough if you have a family or entertain frequently. Consider multi-packs or systems with storage bins to ensure you always have enough ice on hand, much like a water dispenser with an ice maker would provide.
FAQ
What is the best ice cube tray with lid for beginners?
For beginners, the Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays 4-Pack is an excellent starting point. It’s affordable, easy to use, and the flexible silicone bottoms make releasing ice foolproof. The stackable lids help with organization and prevent spills, covering all the basic needs without any complicated features. It is a forgiving and practical choice for anyone new to lidded trays.
How much should I spend on ice cube tray with lid?
You can find excellent ice cube trays with lids for between $15 and $25. This price range typically gets you a multi-pack of high-quality silicone or hybrid trays with good lids. More comprehensive systems with storage bins and scoops can cost upwards of $30. Anything under $10 might compromise on material quality and durability, leading to cracking and frustration.
What features are most important in ice cube tray with lid?
The three most important features are an easy-release mechanism (like flexible silicone), a secure and stackable lid to save space and prevent odors, and construction from BPA-free, food-grade materials. Everything else, like storage bins or special shapes, is a bonus based on personal preference.
How do I maintain my ice cube tray with lid?
Maintenance is simple. Wash your trays regularly, either by hand with soap and water or in the dishwasher if they are dishwasher-safe. This prevents any mineral buildup from water and ensures no flavors are transferred. Allow them to dry completely before refilling to prevent a layer of frost from forming under the lid.
Are expensive ice cube tray with lid worth it?
In some cases, yes. More expensive trays from brands like OXO often feature innovative designs, like no-spill seals or controlled-release lids, that solve common problems. High-end systems with large storage bins are also worth it for those who need a lot of ice. For most users, however, a mid-range, well-reviewed product offers the best balance of price and performance.
What brands make the best ice cube tray with lid?
OXO is consistently praised for its thoughtful, durable designs. Brands like DOQAUS and PHINOX are known for their innovative all-in-one systems with storage bins. Airabc and ChefAide offer fantastic value with high-quality multi-packs. The best brand for you will depend on whether you prioritize innovative features, value, or a complete ice-making system.
How long do ice cube tray with lid typically last?
A good quality ice cube tray made from silicone or sturdy PP plastic should last for several years with proper care. They are designed to withstand constant freezing and thawing. Cheaper, brittle plastic trays are prone to cracking within months, which is why investing in a slightly better model is a good idea.
Can I find good ice cube tray with lid on a budget?
Absolutely. There are many excellent budget-friendly options, especially in multi-packs. The Airabc 4-Pack, for example, offers incredible value without sacrificing key features like easy-release bottoms and stackable lids. You don’t have to spend a lot to get a durable and functional set that will meet your daily ice-making needs.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and review, the DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin stands out as the best overall choice. Its comprehensive all-in-one system, including four sturdy trays, a large storage bin, and a scoop, offers unmatched convenience and organization for any household.
For budget-conscious shoppers, the Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays 4-Pack provides exceptional value. You get four reliable, easy-release trays with stackable lids at a price that is hard to beat.
If you seek premium design and innovation, the OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray is the top contender. Its brilliant sealed lid prevents any spills, making it perfect for crowded or uneven freezers.
Ultimately, choosing the right ice cube tray comes down to your specific needs. Assess your space, capacity requirements, and desired features to select the perfect model that will provide you with fresh, clean ice for years to come.
