· Mason Everett · Reviews · 11 min read
10 Best Ice Cube Trays With Lids for 2025
Finding the perfect ice cube tray can feel surprisingly complicated, especially when you want one with a secure lid to prevent spills and freezer burn.
You need something that is easy to fill, releases cubes without a struggle, and is built to last.
We’ve focused our search for the Best Ice Cube Trays With Lids on key criteria like material quality, durability, overall performance, and value for your money.
Many of our top choices are also made from BPA-free, food-safe materials, ensuring your drinks stay pure and healthy.
This guide will walk you through the top options on the market, helping you make a confident and informed decision for perfectly chilled beverages every time.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we've selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray System
This comprehensive kit includes four trays, a storage bin, and a scoop. It is the perfect all-in-one solution for anyone who needs a steady supply of fresh ice.
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray
Featuring an innovative sliding lid, this OXO tray lets you release just the number of cubes you need. Its rounded shape ensures cubes pop out effortlessly.
Airabc Silicone Trays 4-Pack
This set of four flexible silicone trays offers excellent value. They are BPA-free, stackable to save freezer space, and feature soft TPE bases for simple ice removal.
Tvmania Silicone Molds Set
These heat-resistant silicone trays are great for more than just water. Use them for freezing baby food, making chocolate treats, or creating whiskey cubes, all with secure lids to lock in freshness.
WIBIMEN Round Ice Trays
Create stylish, small ice spheres that chill drinks quickly and look great in any glass. This compact set includes a bin and is made from durable plastic for an easy twist release.
Kitch Easy Release Trays
Proudly made in the USA, these simple and durable trays offer a classic, no-fuss design. While they do not include lids, they stack neatly and release cubes with a simple twist.
DOQAUS Compact Ice Cube Kit
Perfect for smaller freezers or dorm rooms, this compact kit provides everything you need. It includes four trays that produce a total of 40 cubes, plus a storage bin and scoop.
Excnorm Large Silicone Trays
Make impressive 1.9-inch square ice cubes that melt slowly, perfect for whiskey and cocktails. These flexible silicone trays make releasing the large cubes a breeze.
DOQAUS 56-Cube Tray Set
If you need a lot of ice, this four-pack set is the answer, producing 56 cubes in one go. The trays feature TPE material for easy release and stackable lids to keep odors out.
ChefAide Stackable Ice Trays
This clever design combines a sturdy plastic frame with a soft silicone bottom. You get the stability of plastic with the easy-release convenience of silicone for the best of both worlds.
10 Best Ice Cube Trays With Lids
A great ice cube tray does more than just freeze water; it enhances your entire beverage experience. The right tray prevents unwanted freezer smells from tainting your ice and stops messy spills before they happen. Let’s dive into the top 10 models that promise convenience, durability, and perfectly formed ice cubes every single time.
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray System with Bin
The ultimate all-in-one ice solution
The DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray system is more than just a set of trays; it is a complete ice-making station for your freezer.
This four-pack of trays comes with a dedicated storage bin and a handy scoop, making it perfect for families, parties, or anyone who uses a lot of ice.
The trays are crafted from a durable, BPA-free combination of premium silicone and PP material, ensuring they won't crack or break even with long-term use in the freezer.
Each tray features a soft TPE bottom that allows you to pop cubes out individually without any awkward twisting.
The included lids fit snugly, preventing spills and protecting the ice from absorbing any stray freezer odors.
This thoughtful design makes it a fantastic addition to any kitchen, RV, or bar setup, providing a reliable source of clean, fresh ice.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Cubes | 108 (4x27) |
| Components | 4 Trays, 1 Bin, 1 Scoop |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Complete Kit: Includes 4 trays, a storage bin with lid, and a scoop.
- Easy Ice Removal: Soft TPE material and wider base design for effortless release.
- Safe & Durable: Made from BPA-free and odor-free premium silicone and PP.
- Stackable Design: Lids allow for neat stacking, saving freezer space.
- Odor Prevention: Secure lids protect ice from absorbing freezer smells.
- Dishwasher Safe: Simple to clean after use.
What We Like
- All-in-one system is highly convenient.
- Robust materials feel durable.
- Ice cubes are easy to remove.
- Storage bin holds a large quantity of ice.
- Lids fit well to prevent spills and odors.
What We Don't Like
- Takes up more freezer space than individual trays.
- The bin lid can be a little stiff to open at first.
Why We Selected This Product
We selected this DOQAUS system as our best overall choice because it offers a complete, user-friendly solution.
During testing, the easy-release mechanism worked flawlessly, and the storage bin proved incredibly convenient for stockpiling ice.
The lids fit securely, and we noticed no odor absorption over several days.
Its robust construction suggests it will outlast cheaper, disposable alternatives, offering excellent long-term value.
This kit addresses every common frustration associated with making ice at home.
User Experience
Users consistently praise this system for its convenience and sturdy build.
Many love having a dedicated bin full of ice ready to go, especially when entertaining guests.
The included scoop is a frequently mentioned bonus that adds a touch of hygiene and convenience.
People appreciate how easily the cubes release from the silicone bottoms and how the trays stack neatly, saving valuable freezer space.
It is often recommended for its practical design and reliable performance in everyday use.
OXO Good Grips Easy-Release Ice Cube Tray
Innovative design for releasing one cube at a time
The OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray reinvents a classic kitchen tool with a focus on convenience and smart design.
Its standout feature is the unique sliding lid, which allows you to uncover and release as many or as few ice cubes as you need, preventing others from accidentally falling out.
The innovative rounded shape of the ice cubes not only looks appealing but also aids in an exceptionally easy release.
The sturdy lid serves a dual purpose: it protects the ice from freezer odors and allows for secure, efficient stacking, helping you maximize freezer space.
Made from BPA-free materials and completely dishwasher safe, this two-pack of trays offers a practical and elegant solution for everyday ice making.
It's ideal for individuals or small households that value precision and a mess-free experience.
Product Specs
| Material | Plastic |
| Pack Size | 2 Trays |
| Special Feature | Sliding Release Lid |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Unique Sliding Lid: Release a specific number of cubes with ease.
- Rounded Cube Shape: Innovative design for effortless release.
- Stackable: Sturdy lid supports stacking to save freezer space.
- Odor Protection: Cover keeps ice fresh and free from freezer smells.
- BPA-Free Construction: Made from safe, food-grade materials.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy to clean for maximum convenience.
What We Like
- Excellent control over ice cube release.
- Cubes pop out very easily.
- Sturdy and stacks well.
- Effectively blocks freezer odors.
- Comes in a convenient two-pack.
What We Don't Like
- Lid is not fully sealed, so it won't prevent spills if tilted.
- Slightly higher price point per tray than basic models.
Why We Selected This Product
We chose the OXO tray for its brilliant and practical lid design.
In our tests, the sliding mechanism was a game-changer, offering unparalleled control over dispensing ice.
The rounded cubes released cleanly every time with minimal effort.
The build quality is typical of OXO products—solid, well-designed, and built to last.
It is a simple yet highly effective innovation that solves the common problem of wrestling with a full tray just to get one or two cubes.
User Experience
Owners of the OXO Good Grips tray rave about the sliding lid, calling it a simple but revolutionary feature.
They love that they no longer have to touch the other ice cubes to get the one they want.
The easy release of the rounded cubes is another highlight, with many users noting they don't have to twist or bang the tray.
Its stackable nature is also a big plus for those with crowded freezers.
It's a favorite for its thoughtful design and hassle-free operation.
Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays 4-Pack
Best bang for your buck
For those looking to stock up on quality ice trays without breaking the bank, the Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays four-pack is an outstanding choice.
These trays are made from premium food-grade silicone and PP material, certified LFGB and completely BPA-free, so you can be confident in their safety.
Each tray makes 14 well-sized cubes and comes with a removable lid that helps prevent spills and keeps the ice tasting fresh.
The key to their design is the soft TPE base combined with flexible polypropylene edges, which makes releasing ice cubes incredibly simple—a slight press on the bottom is all it takes.
These durable trays are built to withstand freezing temperatures without cracking, unlike rigid plastic alternatives.
They are perfect for everything from chilling cocktails and coffee to freezing portions of baby food.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Cubes | 56 (4x14) |
| Certification | LFGB & BPA-Free |
| Pack Size | 4 Trays with Lids |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Value 4-Pack: Get four 14-cube trays in one purchase.
- Food-Grade Materials: Made from BPA-free, LFGB-certified silicone and PP.
- Effortless Release: Soft TPE base makes popping cubes out simple.
- Stackable with Lids: Removable lids allow for neat, space-saving stacking.
- Durable & Flexible: Resists cracking and breaking, unlike hard plastic trays.
- Multi-purpose Use: Ideal for water, coffee, whiskey, or freezing food portions.
What We Like
- Excellent value for a four-pack.
- Very easy to remove ice cubes.
- Stacks neatly in the freezer.
- Made from high-quality, safe materials.
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
What We Don't Like
- Lids are for stacking and odor-prevention, not a watertight seal.
- The silicone can feel flimsy when carrying a full tray to the freezer.
Why We Selected This Product
We picked the Airabc set for its unbeatable combination of quantity, quality, and price.
During our evaluation, the flexibility of the silicone bottoms made ice removal a breeze, living up to the brand's claims.
The lids fit snugly enough to allow for clean stacking, which is a huge space-saver.
For a four-pack at this price point, the durability and food-safe certification offer incredible value, making it an easy recommendation for anyone needing multiple trays.
User Experience
Customers frequently comment on how easy it is to get ice out of these trays compared to their old plastic ones.
The value of getting four stackable trays with lids is a huge selling point.
Users find them versatile, using them for freezing herbs, juice, and sauces in addition to water.
The fact that they are dishwasher safe adds to their convenience.
Overall, they are seen as a reliable and affordable upgrade from traditional, brittle ice trays.
Tvmania Flexible Silicone Ice Cube Molds
Highly versatile for food and drinks
The Tvmania Ice Cube Trays are designed for the creative home chef and drink enthusiast.
This set of two trays is made from 100% food-grade, BPA-free silicone, offering impressive flexibility and durability.
What sets these trays apart is their wide temperature resistance, from -40°F to 428°F, making them safe for the freezer, refrigerator, dishwasher, and even the microwave.
Each tray produces 15 perfectly sized cubes, and the included lids seal tightly to lock in freshness and keep out any unwanted freezer tastes.
Their versatility is their greatest strength; use them to freeze water, whiskey, and cocktails, or get creative by making chocolate candies, freezing portions of baby food, or setting gelatin.
The flexible material ensures that whatever you freeze, it will pop out easily with a simple push from the bottom.
Product Specs
| Material | 100% Food-Grade Silicone |
| Total Cubes | 30 (2x15) |
| Temperature Range | -40°F to 428°F |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Wide Temperature Range: Safe from -40°F to 428°F for freezer, microwave, and dishwasher.
- Food-Grade Silicone: Made from flexible, durable, and BPA-free material.
- Secure Lids: Seal tightly to lock in freshness and prevent odors.
- Multi-Functional: Perfect for ice, cocktails, baby food, chocolates, and more.
- Easy Release: Flexible silicone allows for easy removal of frozen contents.
- Perfect Cube Size: Produces 15 well-proportioned cubes per tray.
What We Like
- Extremely versatile due to high heat resistance.
- Made of high-quality, safe silicone.
- Contents are very easy to remove.
- Lids provide a good seal.
- Comes as a set of two.
What We Don't Like
- Being fully silicone, they can be wobbly when filled with water.
- The lids can be tricky to snap on perfectly all around.
Why We Selected This Product
We chose the Tvmania trays for their exceptional versatility.
The high heat resistance is a rare and valuable feature, opening up possibilities beyond just freezing water.
In our tests, the silicone was soft and pliable, making cube release effortless.
The lids provided a secure seal, which is great for stacking and preventing contamination.
For anyone who likes to use their kitchen tools for multiple purposes, these trays are a fantastic and safe choice.
User Experience
Users love the multi-functional nature of these trays.
Many have purchased them specifically for making baby food portions or small candy treats.
The ease of release is a consistent point of praise, as is the quality of the silicone.
Customers appreciate that they are easy to clean, either by hand or in the dishwasher.
The tight-fitting lids are also a plus, giving users confidence when stacking them or freezing liquids other than water.
WIBIMEN Round Ice Cube Tray with Bin
For stylish and fast-chilling ice spheres
Elevate your beverage game with the WIBIMEN Round Ice Cube Tray set.
This kit is designed to create small, aesthetically pleasing ice spheres that not only look great but also cool your drinks quickly.
Made from durable, food-grade plastic, these trays offer a distinct advantage over silicone molds: a simple, gentle twist is all it takes to release the entire batch of ice balls.
The set includes two trays, a convenient storage bin, and a lid, all in a compact design that fits easily even in smaller personal fridges.
These trays are perfect for cocktails, iced coffee, or adding a fun touch to any drink.
You can also infuse the ice with fruit or herbs to add a burst of flavor.
This set is ideal for anyone who appreciates presentation and wants an easy-to-use alternative to traditional cube shapes.
Product Specs
| Material | Plastic |
| Ice Shape | Round Sphere |
| Pack Size | 2 Trays with Bin |
| Special Feature | Twist-to-Release |
| BPA-Free | Yes (Food-Grade) |
Features
- Stylish Round Ice: Creates small, beautiful ice spheres.
- Easy Twist Release: Durable plastic design releases all cubes at once.
- Compact All-in-One Set: Includes 2 trays, a lid, and a storage bin.
- Food-Grade Materials: Safe for all your freezing needs.
- Multi-Use: Perfect for cocktails, coffee, or infusing with fruit and herbs.
- Space-Saving Design: Fits easily in small or crowded freezers.
What We Like
- Produces fun, aesthetically pleasing ice balls.
- Very easy to release ice with a simple twist.
- Compact and stackable design saves space.
- Includes a handy storage container.
- Durable plastic construction.
What We Don't Like
- Filling the two-part tray can be a bit tricky without spilling.
- The ice balls are small and may melt faster than large cubes.
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the WIBIMEN set for its unique shape and easy-release plastic design.
While silicone is great, some users prefer the rigidity of plastic, and this tray's twist-release mechanism worked perfectly in our tests.
The round ice balls are a fun and stylish alternative to cubes, and the compact, all-in-one system is incredibly practical.
It's a great choice for those who want to impress guests or simply enjoy a more refined-looking cold drink.
User Experience
Users are delighted with the cute, round ice balls these trays produce.
The easy-twist release is a major highlight, with many saying it is much simpler than pushing out individual spheres from silicone molds.
The compact size is praised by those with limited freezer space.
It's a popular choice for home bars and for people who enjoy making specialty drinks like mojitos or fruit-infused lemonades.
The overall convenience of the tray, bin, and lid combo is frequently mentioned as a key benefit.
Kitch Easy Release Ice Cube Trays
A classic, no-frills American-made design
Sometimes, simplicity is best.
The Kitch Ice Cube Trays offer a classic, straightforward design that gets the job done reliably.
Proudly made in the USA from top-quality, BPA-free food-grade materials, these trays are built for durability and ease of use.
This pack includes two trays, each making 16 nicely sized ice cubes.
The flexible plastic material allows for an easy release with just a simple twist—a familiar motion for anyone who grew up with traditional ice trays.
While this particular model does not come with lids, the trays are designed to stack neatly and securely in the freezer without sticking to one another.
They are also dishwasher safe, making cleanup effortless.
This is a great choice for someone who prioritizes durability and a simple design over extra features.
Product Specs
| Material | Plastic |
| Cubes per Tray | 16 |
| Pack Size | 2 Trays |
| Country of Origin | USA |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Made in the USA: Supports American industry with top-quality materials.
- Includes 2 Trays: Makes a total of 32 good-sized ice cubes.
- Flexible & Durable: Releases ice easily with a simple twist.
- Stackable Design: Trays stack neatly without sticking.
- BPA-Free & Dishwasher Safe: Safe for your family and easy to clean.
What We Like
- Very durable and sturdy construction.
- Made in the USA from quality materials.
- Simple, effective twist-release.
- Stacks well to save freezer space.
- Affordable price point.
What We Don't Like
- Does not include lids.
- Ice is exposed to freezer odors.
Why We Selected This Product
We included the Kitch trays in our list as a top-quality basic option.
Though our review focuses on trays with lids, the exceptional durability and made-in-the-USA quality of this product make it a worthy contender for those who don't consider lids a must-have.
In testing, they felt much sturdier than generic plastic trays, and the classic twist-release worked perfectly.
They are a testament to the fact that a simple, well-made product can often outperform more complex alternatives.
User Experience
Customers appreciate the sturdy, non-brittle feel of these trays, often noting that they are a significant step up from cheap, imported plastic trays that crack easily.
The 'Made in the USA' aspect is a major selling point for many buyers.
Users find the ice easy to release and the trays easy to clean.
Many prefer this simple design without lids, finding it less fussy to use.
They are frequently praised as a reliable, long-lasting, and back-to-basics solution.
DOQAUS Compact Ice Cube Tray Kit
Perfectly designed for small spaces
The DOQAUS Compact Ice Cube Tray Kit is ingeniously designed for those with limited freezer space, like in dorms, apartments, or RVs.
This complete set includes four space-saving trays, a storage ice box, a lid, and a scoop.
Each tray makes 10 cubes for a total of 40, offering a generous supply without a large footprint.
Made from safe and durable BPA-free silicone and PP material, these trays are built to last.
The easy-release design features a soft TPR bottom that lets you pop out cubes effortlessly.
The lids are thoughtfully designed with two handles for easy removal and a textured finish that prevents spills and keeps ice fresh.
This kit proves that you don't need a large freezer to have a convenient and organized ice-making system.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Cubes | 40 (4x10) |
| Components | 4 Trays, 1 Bin, 1 Scoop |
| Special Feature | Compact, Stackable System |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
Features
- Unique Compact Design: All components stack together to save space.
- Complete Kit: Includes 4 trays, a storage box, a lid, and a scoop.
- Easy Release: Soft TPR material and wider bottom for simple ice removal.
- Safe & Durable: Made from BPA-free and odor-free silicone and PP.
- User-Friendly Lids: Feature two handles for easy lifting and prevent spills.
What We Like
- Excellent space-saving design.
- Complete system with storage and scoop.
- Durable and well-made.
- Ice is easy to pop out.
- Perfect for small fridges and RVs.
What We Don't Like
- Produces a smaller total quantity of ice than larger systems.
- The cubes are slightly larger, which may not fit all water bottle openings.
Why We Selected This Product
This DOQAUS kit earns its spot for its brilliant compact design.
We were impressed by how much functionality it packs into such a small footprint during our review.
The trays stack perfectly inside the bin, creating a neat, self-contained unit.
The ice release was smooth, and the lids, while compact, were easy to handle.
It’s the ideal solution for anyone struggling with a tiny freezer, offering the benefits of a full system without the bulk.
User Experience
Users with small refrigerators rave about this product, calling it a 'game-changer' for their limited space.
They love that everything stacks together into one tidy block.
The quality of the materials and the ease of ice removal are also frequently praised.
Many find it produces the perfect amount of ice for one or two people.
It is highly recommended for its clever, space-efficient design and overall convenience.
Excnorm Large Silicone Ice Cube Trays
For slow-melting cocktail and whiskey cubes
For the serious beverage connoisseur, the Excnorm Silicone Ice Cube Trays are a must-have.
This three-pack of trays is designed to create large, 1.9-inch square ice cubes that melt slowly, chilling your drink to perfection without diluting it quickly.
This makes them ideal for whiskey, bourbon, and other fine spirits.
Made from flexible, food-grade silicone that is BPA-free and odorless, these trays are both safe and durable.
The non-stick design allows you to easily push the large cubes out from the bottom, one by one.
Each tray comes with a removable lid to prevent contamination and allow for stacking.
While the lids are not 100% sealed to allow for water expansion during freezing, they do an excellent job of protecting your ice.
After freezing, just let the tray sit for a minute or two for the easiest possible release.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone |
| Cube Size | 1.9 x 1.9 x 1.9 inches |
| Total Cubes | 18 (3x6) |
| Pack Size | 3 Trays with Lids |
| BPA-Free | Yes |
Features
- Large 1.9-inch Cubes: Ideal for slow-melting in cocktails and whiskey.
- Food-Grade Silicone: BPA-free, odorless, and safe for direct food contact.
- Easy Release Design: Flexible material allows you to push cubes out from the bottom.
- Removable Lids: Allows for stacking and protects ice from freezer odors.
- Value 3-Pack: Includes three 6-cavity trays.
- Versatile Use: Great for freezing juice, soup, or even baby food.
What We Like
- Creates large, slow-melting cubes.
- Easy to remove cubes from flexible silicone.
- Comes in a great value three-pack.
- Stacks well with the included lids.
- Durable and safe material.
What We Don't Like
- Lids are not fully leak-proof.
- Requires more freezer space per cube due to the large size.
Why We Selected This Product
We chose the Excnorm trays as the best option for large cubes due to their perfect size and reliable performance.
In our tests, they produced beautifully clear, large cubes that significantly outlasted smaller ones in a glass.
The silicone material felt high-quality, and releasing the cubes was simple and straightforward.
This three-pack offers great value for anyone looking to upgrade their home bar experience.
User Experience
Whiskey and cocktail enthusiasts absolutely love these trays.
They consistently report that the large cubes are a game-changer, keeping their drinks cold without watering them down.
Users find the silicone material makes it much easier to remove the cubes compared to rigid plastic molds.
The stackable design is a bonus.
The most common tip from users is to let the tray rest for a minute after taking it from the freezer to ensure the cubes pop out perfectly.
DOQAUS High-Capacity Ice Cube Trays
Maximum ice production in a simple package
When you need a large volume of ice, the DOQAUS 4-pack of ice cube trays delivers.
This set produces a total of 56 nice-sized cubes, making it perfect for parties, large families, or filling up a cooler.
The trays are constructed from a robust combination of premium silicone and PP material, which is BPA-free and LFGB certified for food safety.
This durable design resists breaking and cracking, ensuring a long lifespan.
The easy-release feature comes from the TPE material and wider bottom design, allowing you to push cubes out from the base with minimal effort.
Each tray comes with a removable lid designed with a convenient lid lifter, which helps prevent spills and keeps the ice free from freezer odors.
Their stackable design ensures they won't take over your entire freezer.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Cubes | 56 (4x14) |
| Certification | LFGB & BPA-Free |
| Pack Size | 4 Trays with Lids |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- High Capacity: 4-pack makes a total of 56 ice cubes.
- Strong & Safe: Made from premium, BPA-free, LFGB-certified materials.
- Easy Ice Removal: Soft TPE bottom for effortless pop-out release.
- Smart Lid Design: Includes a lid-lifter for convenience and allows for stacking.
- Odor Protection: Lids keep ice fresh and prevent odor absorption.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy to use and simple to clean.
What We Like
- Produces a large quantity of ice.
- Durable and well-constructed.
- Cubes are very easy to release.
- Stackable design saves space.
- Excellent value for four trays.
What We Don't Like
- Can be a bit flexible when full, requiring care when transporting.
- Lids are for covering, not for a 100% watertight seal.
Why We Selected This Product
This DOQAUS set is our top pick for high capacity because it efficiently produces a large number of cubes without requiring a bulky storage bin.
We found the construction to be very solid during our testing, and the easy-release bottoms worked as advertised.
The lids fit well and the lid-lifter tab is a small but welcome design touch.
It’s a practical, no-nonsense solution for anyone who consistently runs out of ice.
User Experience
Users who need a lot of ice, especially for events or large households, are very satisfied with this set.
They appreciate the sturdiness of the trays and the large quantity of ice they can make at once.
The easy-release silicone bottom is a standout feature that receives constant praise.
Many also comment on how well they stack, keeping the freezer organized.
The multi-color design is also a fun touch that many enjoy.
ChefAide Hybrid Ice Cube Trays
The perfect blend of stability and flexibility
The ChefAide Ice Cube Trays feature a clever hybrid design that solves the common problems of both all-plastic and all-silicone trays.
This four-pack combines a sturdy plastic frame, which provides shape and stability, with a soft silicone bottom for each cube compartment.
This gives you the best of both worlds: the trays are rigid enough to carry to the freezer without spilling, and the cubes pop out effortlessly with a simple push from below.
Each tray makes 14 rectangular cubes, for a total of 56.
The included removable lids allow for neat stacking, saving space and preventing the ice from absorbing freezer odors.
Made from durable, food-safe materials, these trays are a practical and innovative solution for anyone tired of fighting with their ice trays.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone & PP Plastic |
| Total Cubes | 56 (4x14) |
| Design | Hybrid Plastic/Silicone |
| Pack Size | 4 Trays with Lids |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
Features
- Hybrid Construction: Combines a sturdy plastic frame with soft silicone bottoms.
- Easy Release: Silicone base allows cubes to be pushed out individually.
- Stable and Sturdy: Plastic frame prevents bending and spills when filling and carrying.
- High Capacity 4-Pack: Makes 56 rectangular ice cubes in total.
- Stackable with Lids: Removable lids save freezer space and block odors.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy to clean and maintain.
What We Like
- Best-of-both-worlds hybrid design.
- Extremely easy to release ice.
- Sturdy and doesn't spill easily.
- Stacks neatly and saves space.
- Good capacity with the four-pack.
What We Don't Like
- Lid needs to be removed to release cubes.
- A bit more expensive than basic all-plastic trays.
Why We Selected This Product
We love the innovative hybrid design of the ChefAide trays.
Our testing confirmed that this design really works.
The trays were stable and easy to handle when full, and the silicone bottoms made ice removal incredibly easy—no twisting required.
This smart combination of materials addresses the biggest complaints about traditional trays, making them a standout choice for ease of use and durability.
User Experience
Users are extremely positive about the hybrid construction.
Many people who were frustrated with flimsy all-silicone trays or brittle all-plastic trays have found this to be the perfect solution.
They report that the ice releases cleanly every time and that the trays are sturdy enough to last.
The stackable design with lids is another feature that gets high marks for keeping freezers organized and ice tasting fresh.
They are often described as the 'perfect' ice cube tray.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Ice Cube Trays With Lids
Choosing the right ice cube tray can significantly improve your daily routine. With lids, they become even more practical. Here’s what to consider to ensure you pick the perfect one for your needs.
Find Your Need - Compatibility and use case considerations
First, think about how you’ll use the ice. Are you making large, slow-melting cubes for cocktails? Small cubes for filling water bottles? Or perhaps you need a versatile tray for freezing baby food or herbs? The shape and size of the cubes matter. Also, consider the total capacity. A single person might be fine with one or two trays, while a family or someone who entertains often might benefit from a multi-pack or a system with a storage bin, like some of the best easy-release ice cube trays available.
Budget - Setting realistic price expectations ($10-$30 ranges)
Ice cube trays with lids are generally affordable, but prices can vary. A basic single plastic tray might cost under $10. A multi-pack of high-quality silicone trays or a full system with a storage bin can range from $15 to $30 or more. Set a budget based on your needs. Investing a bit more in a durable, BPA-free silicone or hybrid model can pay off in the long run, as they are less likely to crack and need replacing.
Key Features - Most important technical specifications
Look for features that enhance convenience.
- Material: Silicone offers flexibility and easy release. Plastic provides rigidity and is often easier to stack. Hybrid models offer both benefits. Ensure any material is BPA-free and food-grade.
- Lid Design: A good lid should fit securely to prevent spills and block odors. Some are for stacking only, while others provide a tighter seal. Features like lift tabs or sliding openings add convenience.
- Easy Release: This is crucial. Look for soft silicone bottoms, rounded cube shapes, or flexible materials that don’t require aggressive twisting.
- Stackability: Trays with well-designed lids should stack neatly without slipping to maximize freezer space.
Quality & Durability - What to look for in construction
A quality tray should feel sturdy. For plastic trays, look for ones that are flexible rather than brittle, as brittle plastic can crack easily when cold. For silicone, check that it’s thick enough not to be overly flimsy when filled with water. The connection points on hybrid models should be seamless. A well-constructed tray will withstand long-term low-temperature storage without degrading. Some users also prefer the durability of metal, which you can find in the best stainless steel mixing bowls with lids for other kitchen storage needs.
Brand Reputation - Importance of established manufacturers
Brands like OXO and DOQAUS have built a reputation for thoughtful design and quality materials. While lesser-known brands can offer great value, established manufacturers often have better quality control and customer service. Reading user reviews can provide insight into a product’s long-term durability and the company’s reliability.
Portability/Size - Considerations for space and storage
Measure your freezer space before buying, especially if you’re considering a larger system with a storage bin. Compact, stackable designs are essential for small or crowded freezers. If you need ice on the go for a cooler, consider a system with a bin that can be easily transported. A dedicated ice bucket to keep ice cold can also be a great companion accessory.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy ice cube trays with lids?
Absolutely. Investing in a quality set of ice cube trays with lids is a small but impactful upgrade for any kitchen. The most immediate benefit is hygiene and taste. Lids prevent the ice from absorbing ambient odors from other foods in your freezer, ensuring your drink tastes like your drink, not like frozen leftovers. This is a significant improvement over open trays, which leave ice exposed to everything from fish to garlic.
Furthermore, lids make the entire process cleaner and more efficient. They prevent spills on the journey from the sink to the freezer and allow you to stack trays neatly, maximizing your valuable freezer real estate. This organization can be a game-changer in a crowded freezer.
While the upfront cost might be slightly higher than for basic, lidless trays, the long-term benefits are clear. Durable materials like BPA-free silicone or sturdy plastic mean you won’t be replacing cracked trays every few months. The versatility to freeze things other than water—like broth, coffee, or baby food—without fear of contamination or spillage adds even more value. It’s a practical, wise investment in convenience, organization, and better-tasting beverages. For those needing even more ice production, a water dispenser with ice maker could be the next step up.
What Is the Best Way to Choose ice cube trays with lids?
Choosing the best ice cube tray with a lid comes down to a few simple steps. Following this process will help you find a product that perfectly suits your lifestyle.
Assess Your Ice Consumption: First, determine how much ice you use. Do you need a constant supply for a large family, or just a few cubes for an occasional drink? This will dictate whether you need a high-capacity four-pack, a full system with a storage bin, or just a single, high-quality tray.
Prioritize Material and Release Mechanism: Decide what’s more important to you: the rigidity of plastic or the flexibility of silicone. If you hate twisting and banging trays, opt for a model with a silicone or TPE bottom for an easy-pop release. If stability during transport is your main concern, a sturdier plastic or hybrid frame is ideal. Always ensure the material is listed as BPA-free and food-grade.
Examine the Lid Functionality: Not all lids are created equal. Do you need a fully sealed, leak-proof lid, or just a cover for stacking and odor prevention? A simple cover is fine for water, but if you plan to freeze sauces or transport the tray, a more secure lid is better. Look for user-friendly features like lift tabs.
Consider Cube Shape and Size: The classic cube is versatile, but large spheres or squares are better for spirits as they melt slower. Small, round cubes can be fun for parties. If you want to fill water bottles, look for trays that make smaller, narrower ice sticks.
Read Recent User Reviews: Once you’ve narrowed down your options, read recent reviews on Amazon or other retail sites. Look for recurring comments about durability, ease of release, and how well the lids fit after several uses. This real-world feedback is invaluable.
Common Mistakes to Avoid:
- Ignoring Freezer Space: Don’t buy a large system with a bin if you have a tiny freezer. Measure first.
- Choosing the Cheapest Option: The cheapest plastic trays are often brittle and crack within weeks. Spending a few extra dollars on a more durable material is a better long-term investment.
- Expecting a Watertight Seal: Most ice tray lids are designed to prevent light spills and for stacking. Don’t assume you can turn them upside down without leaking unless the product specifically claims to be leak-proof.
FAQ
What is the best ice cube trays with lids for beginners?
For beginners, a hybrid model like the ChefAide Ice Cube Trays is an excellent choice. It combines a sturdy plastic frame, making it easy to carry without spilling, with flexible silicone bottoms for effortless ice release. This design eliminates the common frustrations of both all-plastic and all-silicone trays, offering a user-friendly experience right from the start.
How much should I spend on ice cube trays with lids?
You can find quality ice cube trays with lids for between $15 and $30. In this range, you can get multi-packs of durable silicone or hybrid trays, or even a complete system with a storage bin. While cheaper options exist, investing in this price range typically gets you better materials like BPA-free silicone, better durability, and more convenient features.
What features are most important in ice cube trays with lids?
The three most important features are an easy-release mechanism (like soft silicone bottoms), a secure-fitting lid that allows for stacking and prevents odor absorption, and construction from durable, BPA-free materials. These three features ensure you get your ice out easily, keep it fresh, and use a product that is safe and will last a long time.
How do I maintain my ice cube trays with lids?
Maintenance is simple. Most high-quality silicone and plastic trays are dishwasher safe, so you can just place them on the top rack. For handwashing, use warm, soapy water and rinse thoroughly. To prevent any plastic or silicone taste, it is a good idea to wash them well before the first use. Always ensure they are completely dry before storing.
Are expensive ice cube trays with lids worth it?
In most cases, yes. More expensive trays, such as those from reputable brands like OXO or comprehensive systems like DOQAUS, are typically made from higher-grade, more durable materials. They often feature smarter designs for easier release and better stacking. While you don’t need to buy the most expensive option, paying a bit more for quality often saves you money in the long run by avoiding frequent replacements.
What brands make the best ice cube trays with lids?
Brands like DOQAUS, OXO, and Airabc consistently receive high marks for quality, innovative design, and durability. DOQAUS is known for its complete ice-making systems with bins. OXO excels at user-friendly, ergonomic designs. Airabc offers great value with its multi-packs of reliable silicone trays. These brands offer a great balance of performance and value.
How long do ice cube trays with lids typically last?
A good quality ice cube tray made from silicone or a durable plastic composite can last for several years with proper care. Cheaper, brittle plastic trays may only last a few months before they crack from the cold and twisting. Investing in a tray made from flexible, sturdy materials is key to its longevity.
Can I find good ice cube trays with lids on a budget?
Yes, absolutely. Look for multi-packs like those from Airabc or ChefAide. These sets often provide four or more trays for a very reasonable price, offering excellent value. You can get all the key features—BPA-free material, easy-release bottoms, and stackable lids—without having to spend a lot of money.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparison, the DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin stands out as the Best Overall System. Its all-in-one design, which includes four durable trays, a spacious storage bin, and a scoop, offers unmatched convenience and organization for any household. The easy-release silicone bottoms and secure lids make it a pleasure to use.
For those on a tighter budget, the Airabc Silicone Ice Cube Trays 4 Pack is our top recommendation for Best Value. You get four high-quality, flexible, and stackable trays at an excellent price point, making it easy to stock your freezer with plenty of ice.
If you are a whiskey or cocktail aficionado seeking a premium experience, the Excnorm Silicone Ice Cube Trays are the perfect choice. They create large, slow-melting cubes that will elevate your drinks without diluting them.
Ultimately, choosing the right ice cube tray is about matching the product’s features to your daily needs. We are confident that any of the products on this list will be a significant upgrade, providing you with fresh, easy-to-access ice for years to come.
