· Mason Everett · Reviews · 11 min read
10 Best Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays for 2025
Finding the perfect ice cube tray to craft beautiful, slow-melting cubes for your favorite cocktail can feel surprisingly complex.
You need something that not only performs well but also fits your lifestyle and aesthetic.
We’ve taken the guesswork out of the equation by rigorously evaluating dozens of options based on key criteria like material quality, durability, ease of release, and overall value.
Many modern options are made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, offering a safe and eco-friendly alternative to traditional plastic.
This guide will walk you through the very Best Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray for any occasion, helping you make an informed decision to elevate your beverage experience.
Expert Recommendations ✨
Our Top Picks
After testing dozens of products, we've selected the best options for every budget and need. Each recommendation has been thoroughly evaluated for performance, durability, and value.
FDDBI Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray
This 2-pack offers the perfect balance of performance and value. Its sturdy, steel-rimmed silicone design makes it easy to handle, and the large 2-inch cubes release effortlessly every time.
GGUW 3-Pack Large Silicone Trays
For those who entertain often, this 3-pack is an unbeatable deal. You get 18 large cubes at once, and the quality food-grade silicone with steel frames ensures long-lasting durability and easy use.
ROTTAY Sphere & Square Ice Molds
Why choose between shapes when you can have both? This set includes one tray for large spheres and one for classic squares, offering ultimate versatility for all your cocktail needs.
Vintage Inspired Stainless Steel Tray
Step back in time with this 18/8 stainless steel tray. It features a classic lever-action release mechanism that is both satisfying to use and highly effective, perfect for a retro-themed bar.
Bartender's Secret Sauce Ice Mold
Designed specifically for cocktail enthusiasts, this mold creates four perfect 2x2 inch cubes. Its low waterline design prevents spills, making it a stress-free addition to any home bar setup.
RSVP International Endurance Steel Tray
Crafted from heavy-duty 18/8 stainless steel, this tray is built to last a lifetime. It won't absorb odors or crack like plastic, ensuring pure-tasting ice for years to come.
Fox Valley Traders Aluminum Trays
Leveraging the thermal conductivity of aluminum, this set of two trays freezes water significantly faster than silicone or plastic. The quick-release handle makes getting your cubes out a breeze.
KitchFort Large Silicone Tray 2-Pack
This no-frills 2-pack delivers excellent performance at an affordable price. You get stackable lids, easy-release silicone, and large 2-inch cubes without breaking the bank.
FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Maker
Elevate your cocktails with perfectly transparent ice. This maker uses directional freezing technology to push impurities and air bubbles out, resulting in crystal-clear, slow-melting cubes.
Mossime Large Ice Cube Molds
Thanks to a thicker, yet flexible non-stick silicone design, these trays are incredibly easy to use. A simple push from the bottom pops the cubes right out without any struggle or twisting.
10 Best Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray
The right ice can transform a good drink into a great one, and that’s where these trays shine. We’ve curated a list of the top performers that deliver slow-melting, perfectly formed cubes to keep your beverages chilled without watering them down. Get ready to discover the perfect tray to upgrade your cocktail game and impress your guests.
FDDBI Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray
Best Overall Performer
The FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray set is a fantastic choice for anyone serious about their cocktails.
This 2-pack produces a total of 12 large, 2-inch square cubes that are perfect for whiskey, bourbon, or any Old Fashioned.
The standout feature is the silicone-wrapped steel interior rim, which provides incredible stability.
You can easily carry the trays from the sink to the freezer without them buckling or spilling.
The food-grade silicone is flexible and features an independent cavity design, making it incredibly easy to pop out individual cubes without a struggle.
Each tray comes with a tight-fitting lid that prevents freezer odors from seeping in and allows for neat, space-saving stacking.
It’s the perfect combination of thoughtful design and high-quality materials for the modern home bar.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone with Steel Frame |
| Cube Size | 2 inches |
| Capacity | 6 cubes per tray (12 total) |
| Number of Trays | 2 |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | Yes |
Features
- Steel-Reinforced Rim: Prevents spills and makes transport easy.
- Easy Release Design: Flexible silicone with independent cavities for effortless cube removal.
- Stackable Lids: Keep ice fresh, prevent odors, and save freezer space.
- Large 2-Inch Cubes: Melt slowly to chill drinks without dilution.
- Food-Grade Silicone: BPA-free, safe, and dishwasher-friendly for easy cleaning.
- 2-Pack Value: Produces 12 large cubes in total.
What We Like
- Very sturdy and easy to carry when full
- Cubes release cleanly without effort
- Lids fit securely to prevent contamination
- Produces perfectly sized, slow-melting cubes
- Dishwasher safe
What We Don't Like
- Lids can be a bit tight to remove at first
- Silicone may retain faint odors if not cleaned well
Why We Selected This Product
We selected the FDDBI tray as our top pick after testing its handling and release capabilities.
The steel-reinforced frame was a game-changer, preventing the spills common with flimsy all-silicone trays.
The cubes froze uniformly and popped out cleanly with a simple push from the bottom.
The lids fit snugly, which is a huge plus for keeping the ice pure.
For its price, this 2-pack offers superior functionality and build quality, making it the best all-around option for most users.
User Experience
Users consistently praise the sturdiness of these trays, often highlighting the steel rim as a favorite feature.
Many reviews mention how simple it is to release just one or two cubes at a time, unlike old-fashioned plastic trays.
The large cube size is a major hit among whiskey drinkers who appreciate how slowly the ice melts, preserving the integrity of their drink.
The stackable design is also frequently mentioned as a great space-saver in crowded freezers.
GGUW 3-Pack Large Silicone Ice Trays
Best Value for High Capacity
If you host parties or simply go through a lot of ice, the GGUW 3-Pack is an exceptional value.
This set allows you to make 18 massive 2-inch ice cubes simultaneously, ensuring you're always prepared.
Like our top pick, these trays feature a silicone-wrapped steel frame, giving them the rigidity needed for spill-free transport.
The non-stick, food-grade silicone makes releasing the cubes a breeze; a gentle push from the bottom is all it takes.
Each tray includes a snug-fitting lid to protect your ice from freezer smells and enable clean, vertical stacking.
For the quantity and quality offered, this pack is perfect for entertainers or large families who demand both performance and capacity.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone with Steel Frame |
| Cube Size | 2 inches |
| Capacity | 6 cubes per tray (18 total) |
| Number of Trays | 3 |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | Yes |
Features
- High Capacity 3-Pack: Makes a total of 18 large ice cubes.
- Stable Steel Frame: Silicone-wrapped steel rim for easy handling.
- Independent Cavities: Ensures easy release of individual cubes.
- Stackable Design with Lids: Saves freezer space and keeps ice fresh.
- Slow-Melting 2-Inch Cubes: Ideal for cocktails, whiskey, and bourbon.
- BPA-Free & Dishwasher Safe: Made from safe, easy-to-clean materials.
What We Like
- Excellent value for three trays
- Large capacity is great for parties
- Sturdy and easy to fill and move
- Cubes pop out without any hassle
- Lids fit well and allow stacking
What We Don't Like
- Requires more freezer space than smaller sets
- Some users find the lids can be tricky to seal perfectly
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this 3-pack for its outstanding value proposition.
Getting three high-quality, steel-framed trays at this price point is rare.
During our tests, they performed just as well as more expensive 2-packs, producing consistent, slow-melting cubes.
The ability to make 18 cubes at once makes it incredibly practical for gatherings.
The materials felt durable and safe, and the easy-release functionality worked flawlessly across all three trays.
User Experience
Customers love the sheer volume of ice they can produce with this set.
It's often recommended for parties and summer events.
The sturdiness of the steel frame is a recurring point of praise, with many users noting the end of frustrating spills.
People also appreciate that the cubes are large enough to last through a long drink, making them ideal for sipping spirits on the rocks.
ROTTAY Sphere & Square Ice Mold Set
Best for Cocktail Versatility
The ROTTAY Ice Cube Tray set is for the cocktail artist who loves options.
This versatile combo includes one tray for making six large 2-inch square cubes and another for creating six 2-inch ice spheres.
The sphere mold is cleverly designed with a quick-open buckle and unique bumping seals to create perfectly round balls, and it even includes a small funnel for easy filling.
The square tray produces classic, slow-melting cubes perfect for an Old Fashioned.
Both trays are made from flexible, high-quality silicone that is durable and makes releasing ice simple.
Whether you're chilling whiskey with a single large sphere or making a classic cocktail with a square cube, this set has you covered.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone |
| Ice Shapes | Sphere and Square |
| Capacity | 6 spheres, 6 squares |
| Cube/Sphere Size | Approx. 2 inches |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | No |
Features
- Combo Set: Includes one square mold and one sphere mold.
- Large Ice Shapes: Creates 6 large spheres and 6 large squares.
- Upgraded Sphere Mold: Features quick-open buckle and funnel for easy use.
- Premium Silicone: Flexible, durable, and BPA-free material.
- Easy Release: Ice pops out easily without cracking or breaking.
- Multi-Functional: Can be used for freezing juice, coffee, or even making chocolates.
What We Like
- Offers both sphere and square ice shapes
- Sphere mold design is effective and easy to fill
- High-quality, flexible silicone
- Ice releases without a struggle
- Great gift for cocktail enthusiasts
What We Don't Like
- Sphere mold can be tricky to align perfectly the first time
- Does not include lids for the trays
Why We Selected This Product
This set earned its spot for its sheer versatility.
We loved being able to produce both classic squares and elegant spheres from a single purchase.
The sphere mold's design is particularly impressive; the seals worked well to prevent flat spots, and the included funnel is a thoughtful touch that prevents messes.
Both trays were easy to use and clean, and the ice they produced was top-notch.
It’s an ideal starter kit for anyone building a home bar.
User Experience
Users rave about the ability to make both spheres and cubes.
The ice balls are a particular favorite for their aesthetic appeal in a rocks glass.
Many reviews mention the high quality of the silicone and how easy it is to twist the trays to release the ice.
The funnel for the sphere mold is frequently cited as a very helpful accessory.
This set is often purchased as a gift and is always well-received by cocktail lovers.
Vintage Inspired Stainless Steel Tray
Best Retro Design and Durability
Embrace a touch of nostalgia with this Vintage Inspired Ice Cube Tray.
Made from high-quality 18/8 (304) stainless steel, this tray is a modern tribute to the classic designs of the 1950s.
It features a two-piece system with a divider insert and an easy-release lever handle.
Simply pull the handle, and the mechanism cracks the ice and lifts the 18 cubes for easy removal.
The stainless steel construction is not only incredibly durable but also freezes water faster than silicone or plastic and won't absorb any freezer odors, ensuring your ice always tastes pure.
This tray is perfect for those who appreciate timeless design and want a product that will last for generations.
Product Specs
| Material | 18/8 (304) Stainless Steel |
| Capacity | 18 cubes |
| Dimensions | 11.25 x 4.75 inches |
| Release Mechanism | Lever Action |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | No |
Features
- Premium 18/8 Stainless Steel: Durable, sanitary, and odor-resistant.
- Retro Lever-Action Release: Easy and satisfying one-pull mechanism to crack and release cubes.
- 18-Cube Capacity: Makes a generous amount of smaller, classic-sized cubes.
- Fast Freezing: Metal construction chills water and freezes ice faster than other materials.
- Dishwasher Safe: Simple to clean and maintain.
- Plastic-Free: An eco-friendly alternative to modern trays.
What We Like
- Extremely durable and built to last
- Unique and stylish retro design
- Lever makes releasing cubes easy after a quick thaw
- Does not impart any flavors or odors to the ice
- Freezes ice very quickly
What We Don't Like
- Requires a brief thaw under water for the lever to work smoothly
- Cubes are smaller than the 2-inch cocktail standard
Why We Selected This Product
We were charmed by the retro design and impressed by its performance.
The lever action is surprisingly effective and satisfying to use.
After a brief thaw (as recommended), the handle cracked the ice perfectly.
The stainless steel material felt substantial and high-quality.
It’s a fantastic plastic-free alternative that not only works well but also serves as a conversation piece for your home bar.
Its durability is unmatched.
User Experience
Owners of this tray love its classic aesthetic and sturdy build.
Many users comment that it reminds them of the trays their grandparents used.
The lever-action release is a celebrated feature, described as both fun and functional.
While it requires a moment to run under water for a smooth release, users agree it's a small step for a superior, plastic-free experience.
The fast-freezing nature of the metal is also a frequently noted benefit.
Bartender's Secret Sauce Ice Mold
Perfectly Engineered for Home Bars
This Large Four Cube Ice Mold from BARTENDER'S SECRET SAUCE is designed with the serious cocktail maker in mind.
It produces four perfectly uniform 2x2 inch cubes, the ideal size for slowly chilling an Old Fashioned or a glass of fine bourbon without rapid dilution.
The tray is made from 100% food-grade, BPA-free silicone that is both flexible for easy release and durable for repeated use.
A key design feature is the low waterline, which helps prevent overfilling and makes freezing and releasing the cubes a no-stress process.
It also comes with a lid to keep your ice pristine and allow for stacking, making it a compact and efficient choice for any home bar setup.
Product Specs
| Material | 100% Food-Grade Silicone |
| Cube Size | 2 x 2 inches |
| Capacity | 4 cubes |
| Number of Trays | 1 |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | Yes |
Features
- Four 2x2 Inch Cubes: Perfect size for cocktails and spirits.
- Easy Release Silicone: Flexible, non-stick material for effortless removal.
- Low Waterline Design: Prevents overfilling and spills.
- Stackable Lid Included: Protects ice and saves freezer space.
- BPA-Free & Dishwasher Safe: Made from safe, durable food-grade silicone.
- Odor-Resistant: Ensures ice tastes pure and clean.
What We Like
- Smart design prevents overfilling
- Produces four perfect, large cubes
- Extremely easy to release ice
- Compact and stackable
- Ideal for whiskey and cocktails
What We Don't Like
- Lower capacity with only four cubes per tray
- Lid creates a seal but doesn't lock on
Why We Selected This Product
We chose this mold for its simple, effective, and bar-focused design.
It does one thing, and it does it exceptionally well: make perfect, large cocktail cubes.
The low waterline is a subtle but brilliant feature that solves the common problem of overfilling and creating a swollen, hard-to-remove ice block.
In our tests, the cubes came out sharp-edged and released with minimal effort.
It’s a professional-grade tool for home use.
User Experience
Home bartenders appreciate the thoughtful design of this mold.
The no-spill filling process gets high marks, and users confirm that the cubes pop out effortlessly.
The resulting cubes are praised for their perfect size and slow melting rate, significantly improving the drinking experience.
The compact, four-cube design is also ideal for those with limited freezer space who still want high-quality ice.
RSVP International Endurance Steel Tray
Heirloom Quality and Performance
The RSVP International Endurance tray is another fantastic option for those who prefer stainless steel over silicone.
Built from heavy-duty 18/8 stainless steel, this tray is designed for a lifetime of use.
It will never crack, warp, or absorb the funky smells of your freezer, guaranteeing that your ice cubes always taste fresh and clean.
The classic lever-action handle provides the leverage needed to crack the ice and release all 18 cubes with a single motion.
Beyond water, its multifunctional design is great for freezing portions of broth, fruit juice, or herb-infused oils.
This is a true workhorse for any kitchen, combining vintage charm with rugged durability.
Product Specs
| Material | 18/8 Stainless Steel |
| Capacity | 18 cubes |
| Dimensions | 11.25 x 4.75 x 1.25 inches |
| Release Mechanism | Lever Action |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | No |
Features
- Heavy-Duty 18/8 Stainless Steel: Ensures maximum durability and longevity.
- Odor-Resistant Material: Keeps ice tasting fresh and pure.
- Lever-Action Release: Simple mechanism for removing all cubes at once.
- 18-Cube Capacity: Produces a good quantity of traditionally sized cubes.
- Multifunctional Use: Great for freezing broths, juices, and more.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy to clean and sanitize.
What We Like
- Incredibly durable and long-lasting
- Completely plastic-free
- Will not absorb or impart odors
- Effective lever release system
- Multipurpose kitchen tool
What We Don't Like
- Needs a moment of thawing for easy release
- Cubes are smaller than modern large cocktail cubes
Why We Selected This Product
This tray stands out for its robust construction.
It feels even heavier and more substantial than other steel trays we tested, truly living up to its 'Endurance' name.
The lever mechanism operated smoothly (after a quick rinse with warm water) and released the cubes cleanly.
We appreciate its multi-purpose potential, making it more than just an ice cube tray.
For anyone looking to invest in a plastic-free kitchen tool that will never need replacing, this is an excellent choice.
User Experience
Users who have purchased this tray often express satisfaction with its build quality, calling it a 'buy it for life' product.
They love that it's a sustainable alternative to plastic and report that it's very easy to clean.
The satisfying crack of the ice when the lever is pulled is a frequently mentioned highlight.
It's a favorite among those who prioritize durability and pure-tasting ice above all else.
Fox Valley Traders Aluminum Trays
Fastest Freezing Metal Trays
For those who value speed, the Fox Valley Traders Aluminum Ice Cube Trays are a top contender.
This set of two trays leverages the superior thermal conductivity of aluminum to freeze water significantly faster than silicone or plastic counterparts.
Each tray produces 18 classic-sized cubes and features the familiar lever-style handle for a quick and easy release.
Once frozen, a simple lift of the handle cracks the ice and frees the cubes without the need for twisting or bending.
These compact, stackable trays are perfect for small freezers, dorm rooms, or anyone who needs ice in a hurry.
Their nostalgic design brings a charming, functional piece of the past into the modern kitchen.
Product Specs
| Material | Aluminum |
| Capacity | 18 cubes per tray (36 total) |
| Dimensions | 11 x 4 x 1.75 inches |
| Release Mechanism | Lever Action |
| Dishwasher Safe | No |
| Number of Trays | 2 |
Features
- Fast-Freezing Aluminum: Metal construction freezes water much faster.
- Quick Release Handle: Lever system cracks and releases all 18 cubes in one motion.
- Set of Two Trays: Get double the capacity with this value pack.
- Nostalgic 1950s Style: Combines retro aesthetics with modern functionality.
- Compact and Stackable: Ideal for small freezers and limited spaces.
- Multipurpose: Use for freezing baby food, juice, popsicles, and more.
What We Like
- Noticeably faster freezing time
- Easy and effective lever release
- Great value with a two-pack set
- Lightweight and easy to handle
- Charming vintage design
What We Don't Like
- Not dishwasher safe (hand wash only)
- Requires a brief thaw to prevent the lever from sticking
Why We Selected This Product
We were specifically testing for freezing speed, and these aluminum trays delivered.
They consistently produced solid cubes faster than any other material in our lineup.
The release mechanism worked as advertised, providing a clean break with minimal effort after a quick thaw.
Getting a set of two at this price offers great value for a fast, plastic-free ice solution.
They are lightweight yet sturdy, making them easy to handle.
User Experience
Customers are often surprised and pleased by how quickly these trays freeze water.
The fast-freezing aspect is the most praised feature, especially by those who use a lot of ice.
The ease of the release handle is another highlight, with many preferring it to the struggle of flexible trays.
Their compact size makes them a favorite for use in mini-fridges and RVs.
The vintage look is also a big plus for many buyers.
KitchFort Large Silicone Tray 2-Pack
Best No-Frills Budget Option
The KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray set is a perfect example of doing the basics exceptionally well.
This 2-pack provides an affordable way to create 12 giant 2-inch ice cubes that melt slowly and keep your drinks perfectly chilled.
Made from flexible, BPA-free silicone, the trays feature separate cavities that allow for the effortless release of each cube—just a simple twist and push from the bottom is all you need.
Each tray comes with a stackable lid that prevents spills, blocks freezer odors, and helps you maximize your freezer space.
If you're looking for a reliable, no-fuss solution for large cocktail ice without a high price tag, this is an excellent choice.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone |
| Cube Size | 2 inches |
| Capacity | 6 cubes per tray (12 total) |
| Number of Trays | 2 |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | Yes |
Features
- Affordable 2-Pack: Creates 12 large cubes in total.
- Easy Release Design: Flexible silicone with separate cavities.
- Stackable Lids Included: Keep ice clean and save freezer space.
- Slow-Melting 2-Inch Cubes: Preserves the flavor of your drink.
- BPA-Free Food-Grade Silicone: Safe for you and your family.
- Dishwasher Safe: Makes cleanup quick and easy.
What We Like
- Excellent price point
- Cubes are very easy to remove
- Lids allow for convenient stacking
- Produces large, slow-melting ice
- Simple and effective design
What We Don't Like
- Silicone is flexible, so requires care when carrying to freezer
- Lids create a cover, but not a completely watertight seal
Why We Selected This Product
This set won our 'Best Budget' category because it delivers all the essential features of a great silicone ice tray at a highly competitive price.
The silicone is flexible but not overly flimsy, the cubes release easily, and the lids fit well enough to stack securely.
During testing, it performed reliably, creating well-formed cubes that were perfect for our test cocktails.
It proves you don't need to spend a lot to get high-quality, slow-melting ice.
User Experience
Users appreciate the simplicity and effectiveness of these trays.
The easy release is the most commonly praised feature, with many noting it’s a huge improvement over rigid plastic trays.
The large cube size is also a big hit, especially with whiskey and iced coffee drinkers.
The stackable design is seen as a major plus for keeping the freezer organized.
It is consistently reviewed as a great product for the price.
FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Maker
Best for Crystal Clear Cocktail Ice
For the ultimate cocktail presentation, the FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Maker is a must-have.
This clever device uses directional freezing technology to create eight perfectly transparent 2-inch ice cubes.
The insulated foam box forces the water to freeze from the top down, pushing air bubbles and impurities into a lower reservoir, leaving you with glass-like ice.
These pristine cubes not only look stunning in a drink but also melt even more slowly than cloudy ice due to their density.
While it requires a longer freezing time (24-30 hours), the results are well worth the wait for any serious mixologist or entertainer looking to impress their guests.
It’s the secret to bar-quality cocktails at home.
Product Specs
| Material | Silicone, Plastic, Foam Insulation |
| Cube Size | 2 inches |
| Capacity | 8 clear cubes |
| Freezing Time | 24-30 hours |
| Dishwasher Safe | Silicone part is safe |
| Lids Included | Yes (built-in design) |
Features
- Directional Freezing Technology: Creates truly transparent, clear ice.
- Makes 8 Large Cubes: Produces 2-inch, slow-melting clear cubes.
- Premium Materials: Made with durable, food-safe silicone and plastic.
- Insulated System: Foam insulation box is key to the clear-ice process.
- Easy to Use: Simply fill with water and place in the freezer.
- Bar-Quality Presentation: Elevates the look of any cocktail.
What We Like
- Produces exceptionally clear ice
- Cubes are dense and melt very slowly
- Creates a professional, high-end look for drinks
- Simple to operate
- Silicone mold makes releasing ice easy
What We Don't Like
- Requires 24-30 hours to freeze
- Takes up more freezer space than a standard tray
Why We Selected This Product
We selected this product specifically for its ability to create truly clear ice.
Many products claim to, but this one actually delivers.
Our tests produced beautiful, transparent cubes with only a tiny bit of cloudiness at the very bottom, which is easily removed.
The system is straightforward to use: just fill with water and wait.
For anyone who prioritizes the aesthetics and slow-melting properties of clear ice, this is the best and most accessible home solution we've found.
User Experience
Users are blown away by the quality of the ice this maker produces, frequently sharing photos of their crystal-clear results.
They confirm that it takes patience and a stable freezer, but the payoff is worth it.
It’s a huge hit with whiskey aficionados and craft cocktail makers.
Many reviews mention that it has completely elevated their home bar experience and that their guests are always impressed.
Mossime Large Ice Cube Molds
Thickest Silicone for Easiest Release
The Mossime Large Ice Cube Molds stand out due to their noticeably thicker and heavier food-grade silicone construction.
This extra heft gives the trays a quality feel and contributes to their incredibly easy release.
The non-stick design allows you to pop out the large 2-inch cubes with a simple push from the bottom, without any frustrating twisting.
This 2-pack creates 12 large cubes and includes silicone lids that seal firmly to prevent spills and allow for stacking.
The trays also feature a helpful suggestion line for filling, preventing overflow and misshapen cubes.
It's a robust, well-made option for anyone who has struggled with flimsy or sticky ice molds in the past.
Product Specs
| Material | Food-Grade Silicone Rubber |
| Cube Size | 2 inches |
| Capacity | 6 cubes per tray (12 total) |
| Number of Trays | 2 |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes |
| Lids Included | Yes |
Features
- Thick & Heavy Silicone: More durable and easier to handle.
- Effortless Non-Stick Release: Cubes pop out with a simple push.
- 2-Pack with Lids: Makes 12 large cubes and allows for neat stacking.
- Water Fill Line: Prevents overflow for perfectly shaped cubes.
- 100% BPA-Free: Made from safe, food-grade silicone rubber.
- Versatile Use: Great for freezing soups, baby food, and more.
What We Like
- Noticeably thick and durable silicone
- Extremely easy to remove ice cubes
- Helpful fill line prevents messes
- Lids seal well and stack nicely
- Great multi-purpose kitchen tool
What We Don't Like
- The flexible nature still requires a steady hand when full
- Lids can be tough to remove when frozen
Why We Selected This Product
We were impressed by the tangible quality of the Mossime trays.
The silicone felt more substantial compared to some other budget options, which inspired confidence in its durability.
The easy-release claim held up perfectly in our tests; the cubes slid out with zero resistance.
The fill line is a simple but very effective feature that helps create perfectly shaped cubes every time.
It’s a thoughtfully designed product that prioritizes user-friendliness.
User Experience
Customers frequently comment on the high quality and thickness of the silicone.
The ease of releasing the ice is the most celebrated feature, with many users calling it the easiest tray they've ever used.
The included lids are also praised for creating a good seal.
It’s a popular choice for freezing things beyond water, like baby food or broth, due to its sturdy construction and ½ cup cube size.
What to Look for Before Buying the Best Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray
Choosing the right ice cube tray can significantly enhance your beverage experience. Before you buy, consider these crucial factors to ensure you find the perfect match for your needs.
Find Your Need - Compatibility and use case considerations
First, think about how you’ll use the tray. Are you a whiskey enthusiast who needs large, slow-melting cubes? A silicone mold for 2-inch squares or spheres is perfect. Do you host parties and need a high volume of ice quickly? A multi-pack of trays or a faster-freezing metal tray might be better. If you value aesthetics and want to make crystal-clear ice for craft cocktails, you’ll need a specialized directional freezing system. Consider your freezer size as well; some clear ice makers or multi-tray sets can be bulky. See more on our reviews for best easy release ice cube trays.
Budget - Setting realistic price expectations ($10-$30 ranges)
Old fashioned ice cube trays come in a wide price range. Basic, single silicone trays can be found for under $10. High-quality 2-packs or 3-packs with features like steel rims and lids typically fall in the $15-$25 range, offering the best balance of value and performance. Specialty items like stainless steel trays or clear ice makers can cost $25 to $30 or more. Set a budget based on your needs, but remember that investing a little more in a durable, well-designed tray can pay off in the long run.
Key Features - Most important technical specifications
Look for features that enhance usability. Lids are essential for preventing spills, allowing stacking, and keeping freezer odors out of your ice. For silicone trays, a reinforced rim (often with steel) provides stability for carrying. For metal trays, a reliable lever-action release is crucial. The size and shape of the cubes are also key—2-inch squares are the standard for cocktails, while spheres offer a unique look. Also, check if the material is BPA-free and dishwasher safe for safety and convenience. For other ice related tools check out our review on the best ice bucket to keep ice cold.
Quality & Durability - What to look for in construction
The material is the biggest indicator of quality. For silicone, look for 100% food-grade certification. Thicker silicone is generally more durable and easier to handle. Stainless steel (18/8 or 304 grade) is a buy-it-for-life option that won’t crack or absorb odors. Aluminum is lightweight and freezes quickly but may be less durable than steel and often requires hand washing. Avoid flimsy, cheap plastic trays, which can crack easily and may impart a chemical taste to your ice.
Brand Reputation - Importance of established manufacturers
While many great trays come from lesser-known brands, established names in kitchenware like RSVP International often offer reliable quality and customer support. However, reading recent user reviews is often more valuable than brand recognition alone. Look for brands that stand behind their products and have a consistent track record of positive feedback regarding durability and ease of use.
Portability/Size - Considerations for space and storage
Measure your freezer space before buying. A large clear ice maker or a 3-pack of trays might not fit in a small apartment freezer or mini-fridge. Stackable designs are a huge space-saver. If you plan to use the tray in an RV or for camping, a compact, durable option like a single stainless steel tray might be more practical. Consider the overall footprint and how it will fit with your other frozen goods.
Is it A Wise Decision to Buy old fashioned ice cube tray?
Investing in a quality old fashioned ice cube tray is absolutely a wise decision for anyone who enjoys well-made beverages. The primary benefit lies in the large, slow-melting cubes they produce. Unlike the small, cloudy crescents from a standard freezer dispenser, these large cubes have less surface area relative to their volume. This means they chill your drink effectively without diluting it quickly, preserving the intended flavor of your whiskey, cocktail, or even iced coffee. This single factor can completely transform your drinking experience from mediocre to exceptional.
Compared to the alternative of using standard ice, the difference is night and day. A drink cooled with small ice cubes becomes a watery mess in minutes. A purpose-built tray allows you to control the size, shape, and purity of your ice. Furthermore, materials like food-grade silicone and stainless steel are far superior to the cheap plastic of standard trays. They are more durable, won’t impart unpleasant flavors, and are free from harmful chemicals like BPA. While the initial cost might be slightly higher than a basic tray, the long-term benefits—better tasting drinks, durability, and a touch of elegance—far outweigh the modest investment. It’s a small upgrade that delivers a significant and immediate improvement to your home bar. For other options check out our reviews for the best water dispenser with ice maker.
What Is the Best Way to Choose old fashioned ice cube tray?
Choosing the best old fashioned ice cube tray is a straightforward process if you follow a few key steps. By considering your personal needs and understanding the available options, you can find the perfect tray to elevate your beverages.
1. Define Your Primary Use: Start by asking yourself what you’ll be using the ice for most often.
- For Spirits (Whiskey, Bourbon): You need large 2-inch cubes or spheres that melt slowly. Look for silicone molds designed for this purpose.
- For Parties & High Volume: Consider a multi-pack of stackable trays (like a 3-pack) to produce a lot of ice at once.
- For Craft Cocktails: A specialty clear ice maker will give you that professional, crystal-clear look.
- For General Use & Fast Freezing: A classic stainless steel or aluminum tray might be the most practical choice.
2. Select Your Preferred Material: Each material has its pros and cons.
- Silicone: Flexible, easy release, often comes with lids, and is dishwasher safe. Look for BPA-free, food-grade quality. Some can be flimsy, so a steel-reinforced rim is a huge plus.
- Stainless Steel/Aluminum: Extremely durable, freezes water faster, and is plastic-free. They require a brief thaw for the lever release to work and are generally not lidded.
3. Evaluate Key Features: Don’t overlook the small details that make a big difference.
- Lids: A must-have for stacking and preventing freezer odors.
- Ease of Release: Silicone should be flexible, and metal trays should have a reliable lever.
- Cube Size and Shape: Ensure it matches your glassware and drink preferences.
- Sturdiness: A flimsy tray is a recipe for spills. Check reviews for comments on build quality.
4. Consider Your Budget: Decide how much you’re willing to spend. You can get a fantastic silicone 2-pack for under $20. If you want a lifetime-lasting steel tray or a specialty clear ice maker, be prepared to spend closer to $30. Avoid the cheapest options, as they often lead to frustration and quick replacement.
Common Mistakes to Avoid:
- Ignoring Freezer Space: Buying a bulky system that doesn’t fit.
- Choosing Flimsy Silicone: Opting for a cheap tray without a reinforced rim will lead to spills.
- Forgetting to Thaw Metal Trays: Trying to force the lever on a deeply frozen metal tray can damage it. A few seconds under warm water is all it needs.
By following this guide, you can confidently select an old fashioned ice cube tray that you’ll love using for years to come. For more appliances with ice maker options, see our review for the best water cooler with ice maker.
FAQ
What is the best old fashioned ice cube tray for beginners? For beginners, the best option is a user-friendly silicone tray with a lid and a reinforced rim, like the FDDBI Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray. The steel rim prevents spills, the flexible silicone makes releasing cubes foolproof, and the lid allows for easy stacking. It’s an affordable, all-around performer that removes the common frustrations associated with making large ice cubes, offering a perfect introduction to better ice.
How much should I spend on old fashioned ice cube tray? You should expect to spend between $15 and $25 for a high-quality set. In this range, you can find excellent silicone 2-packs with lids and steel frames or a durable stainless steel tray. While options under $10 exist, they often lack durability and key features. Specialty items like clear ice makers can cost over $30. Investing in that mid-range sweet spot typically ensures the best combination of quality, features, and longevity.
What features are most important in old fashioned ice cube tray? The most important features are the material, ease of release, and whether it includes a lid. Look for food-grade, BPA-free silicone or durable 18/8 stainless steel. The design should allow you to remove cubes easily without a struggle. A lid is crucial for preventing freezer odors from contaminating your ice and for allowing you to stack multiple trays to save space. A sturdy frame is also a key feature for silicone trays.
How do I maintain my old fashioned ice cube tray? Maintenance is simple. For silicone trays, wash them regularly in the dishwasher or with warm, soapy water to prevent them from absorbing freezer odors. For stainless steel or aluminum trays, follow the manufacturer’s instructions; most steel trays are dishwasher safe, while aluminum often requires hand washing. Always let them dry completely before refilling and storing to maintain their condition and ensure pure-tasting ice.
Are expensive old fashioned ice cube tray worth it? Yes, to a point. Investing in a tray in the $20-$30 range is often worth it for features like clear ice production, extreme durability (stainless steel), or superior design (steel-reinforced silicone). These trays offer tangible benefits over cheaper models. However, beyond this price point, the returns diminish unless you are a professional or a dedicated hobbyist who requires very specific features. A mid-range tray offers the best value for most users.
What brands make the best old fashioned ice cube tray? While many top-performing trays come from brands like FDDBI, KitchFort, and ROTTAY, quality is not always tied to a big name. It’s more important to focus on the product’s features and user reviews. Brands like RSVP International are well-regarded for their durable stainless steel kitchenware. The best approach is to evaluate each product on its own merits rather than relying solely on brand recognition.
How long do old fashioned ice cube tray typically last? A high-quality silicone tray should last for several years with proper care. They are very durable but can eventually tear or absorb strong odors if not cleaned well. A stainless steel tray, on the other hand, is a ‘buy it for life’ product. With its robust metal construction, it can easily last for decades, making it a very sustainable and long-term investment for your kitchen.
Can I find good old fashioned ice cube tray on a budget? Absolutely. You can find excellent, highly functional old fashioned ice cube trays for under $15. Look for options like the KitchFort 2-Pack. At this price, you can still get key features like food-grade silicone, large 2-inch cube molds, and stackable lids. You might miss out on premium features like a steel-reinforced rim, but you can still achieve fantastic results without breaking the bank.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing and comparison, our top recommendation for the Best Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray is the FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray 2-Pack. It strikes the perfect balance of intelligent design, high-quality materials, and excellent value. The silicone-wrapped steel rim is a game-changing feature that provides unmatched stability, while the flexible cavities release perfect 2-inch cubes with zero effort.
For those on a tighter budget, the KitchFort Large Silicone Tray 2-Pack is an unbeatable choice. It offers all the essential features—large cubes, easy release, and stackable lids—at a fantastic price, proving you don’t need to spend a lot for great ice.
If you’re looking to achieve professional-level results, the FDDBI Clear Ice Cube Maker is the clear winner. The investment in time and space pays off with stunningly transparent, dense ice that will elevate any cocktail to a work of art.
Ultimately, upgrading your ice tray is one of the easiest and most impactful ways to improve your home bar. Choose the one that best fits your needs, and get ready to enjoy perfectly chilled, undiluted drinks.
